City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill - Westbury
Ahi Tuna Tartare
Avocado, Citrus Vinaigrette, Mache, Spiced Crema, House Chips
Avocado Salsa Verde, Smashed Yukon, Chorizo Vinaigrette
Very nice as alwats
Dinner with mother and mother-in-law
Overall would have been five stars save a strange remark at the end of our brunch. Our food was delicious, atmosphere lovely, great sun blocking and helpful service. While 💰 the bill, my husband, who had had a cup of hot coffee previously, asked for a refill. The answer he received was “we don’t do refills “.
This was a $150 brunch for four people, I have no problem with them charging for extra iced coffee or sodas, but not one refill on a cup of coffee? Seems penny wise and pound foolish to me. Left a bad impression.
Our sever Jennifer went above and beyond to provide us fantastic service. We will definitely be returning here again.
Food was really good, they were very attentive. I had the lobster mac and cheese, it was really good.
The food was excellent. The service was superb.
all was fine until the bill. way too expensive for what was paid for
Great for outdoor dining. Went there twice for lunch. Excellent, tasty menu. Great service. Would definitely go again.
Good food. Sat in the bar area. Our server was just wonderful and efficient.
Food was good but expensive,the waitress was knowledgeable and polite but a little busy because the bus boys were standing around goofing off and on their phones not filling the water or cleaning the tables it.so was annoying,I won’t be back
So good to be back!!! And just as I remembered, too…..delicious food, lovely ambiance and meticulous service…..thank you!
Great bartenders great service
The food was awesome. My fiancé chose the night we went to propose. The people at the bar all followed him back from the bathroom and watched him propose to me! Certainly was a surprise!
Our waitress Jen was very sweet and accommodating as one of our guests had a food allergy. She was efficient and the food was absolutely outstanding as usual. We are definitely repeat diners. Thank you for another lovely dining experience!
Eh. Not worth it to go back.
Service was efficient but did not check in regularly.. food was good.
Great food and great service. Lunch atmosphere on a weekday was quiet
Great service and food...would definitely go back again
A disaster !
Service was very very slow . Meal was presented with parts missing. The crackers on a Mediterranean board ! Asked if we wanted taco chips with it instead ???? Waitress offered to reorder we did but that second order took over half hour for 4 fish tacos! Manager comped us two glasses of Sangria- nice gesture
We have eaten here many many times with an excellent dining experience
Today was not
The food was excellent. The service seemed to be a bit off. We went on a Monday night. We had reservations and got our table immediately. We got our drinks and were waiting. Our entrees were brought out before the appetizers. Bread came out 20 minutes after the drinks, and the olive oil 10 minutes later. The waiter was quite apologetic and clearly admitted he had been working a lot of double shifts. They must have been short staffed elsewhere.
But, the redeeming point was that the food was excellent.
Excellent dining experience
Everything was perfect. They have parking, food was delicious and service was great. Most importantly to me, the restaurant is BEAUTIFUL !!!!
The noise level was intolerable. We had to wait approximately 20 minutes to be seated with reservations. Once seated, we waited an additional 20 minutes to be waited on. The able has only two setting and we had to 'flag' down a waited to gel the additional two settings.
I have been here many times and my experiences were quite satisfactory. Unfortunately, this time it was disappointing.
Was shaded & breezy on the patio under an umbrella, perfect for our lunch. Mediterranean Board was delicious. We had it as a starter, not realizing how much food it would be. Took home most of our mains, which were generous portions (sandwich & Cobb Salad). Would certainly go back again.
Everything was delicious! Cute indoors but we sat outside which is still nice. Everything we ordered was delicious! Short rib, Salmon, and the Burrata Caprese for appetizer
waitress was fabulous‼️
great food. fun night.
No lunch menu anymore. Prices also went up compared to pre-pandemic prices.
But staff was great and outdoor seating was nice.
Business lunch required some level of quietness, which we had by dining outdoors.
We've been quite a few times pre pandemic and this experience just fell a little short. For being a Monday night, service was slow and they didn't seem to have enough staff. We had a 730 reservation and it took almost a full 2 hours for one appetizer and 2 entrees, no drinks no dessert. Food was just okay, nothing that stood out more than usual. There was also a group of 5 at the bar that was blocking the walk way while waiting for their table that was quite loud but yet despite blocking the area for staff to walk through and being loud, no one said anything to them. It was just okay. Not planning on going back anytime soon
Everything was absolutely amazing!
Crystal was an amazing server!
Awesome Sunday brunch
The experience was overall excellent and they had a live jazz band playing. Can you say cherry on top of the sundae? Great experience. Can’t wait to go back.
Sat for 30 minutes before anyone even came over, not their fault, you are seriously understaffed. Unimpressed with outdoor area, freezing cold, no attempt at warmth. We left after not even receiving a glass of water.
The lump crab Benedict was 1) very fishy & 2) was not lump crab but similar to frozen crab cakes....breaded & fried, not fresh crab meat
my boyfriend had ordered take out the week prior and decided it was definitely a place to try out for a date night. WONDERFUL experience. what stole the show for us was the charred octopus appetizer; cooked and seasoned PERFECTLY! Seth was our waiter and was absolutely wonderful; making sure we felt welcomed. can’t wait to go again!
Good food and service, but overpriced and a little unorganized when checking in.
We had the lobster Mac and cheese, there was only a couple pieces of lobster which sucked but it was good, spinach dip is delish, and we also got the wagyu beef sliders. The sliders are way too overpriced and not worth it - we only got 3 for $16, we were expecting 4 at least. We also got the watermelon sangria which was really good!
For the price the quantity of the food should be more.
We ate outside and it was cold but nicely lit and they tried to make it warmer with heaters. It didn’t look like they followed the 6 ft rule inside last night and it was packed so we were happy to sit outside. Great ambiance outside.
Overall, decent experience but for the quantity and quality of food it’s way too pricy.
Food was excellent! So many gluten free options, super accommodating & attentive waiter ! They were on top of the space heaters too
City Cellar is a great place for all. Couples, families, friends. I went out with a friend and it was an excellent experience. Great service and food. Most importantly we weren't rushed.
This was a nice area and I loved the decor. The food was outstanding but the environment was a little noisy. They have a nice outdoor area that is nice if you want dinner outside. However, our service wasn’t the best. Our food took a really long time to come out and even to get our drinks it took longer than expected on a not so busy Friday. Our server was very rude when it came to talking to her about the happy hour deals they had and doing any special things for my grandma’s birthday that day. When she brought out our small plates for our appetizers she threw the places towards us like we were dogs and almost knocked over my grandfathers wine while doing it. Her attitude only changed as our bill was increasing at the restaurant. On top of that she charged me for 2 extra items on my bill that I didn’t order. I now have to go through my bank to get these refunded. Make sure you check your bill at this place to make sure things add up.
City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill - Westbury is rated 4.4 stars by 2772 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.