14 Best Italian Restaurants In Merrimac

14 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Sortino’s Italian Kitchen - Wisconsin Dells restaurant

1. Sortino’s Italian Kitchen - Wisconsin Dells

4.4

Awesome(69)

$$$$

• Italian • Delton

Booked 2 times today

Great service, great company, loved everything! One of my go to places in the Dells!

2. Cento

4.7

Exceptional(2751)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Booked 68 times today

Service and food was spectacular! We had the table next to the kitchen. A very special night for our whole family. Cento is awesome!

A photo of Sarento's Italian Restaurant restaurant

3. Sarento's Italian Restaurant

4.4

Awesome(587)

$$$$

• Italian • Wisconsin Dells / Lake Delton

Booked 6 times today

My husband and I ordered the bruschetta appetizer and split the tenderloin trio with a salad and fettuccine Alfredo sides. Delicious! Would eat the same thing again. My only complaint was our server tended to disappear and she spoke so quietly we had to ask her to repeat herself constantly. She was friendly though.

A photo of North Italia - Madison restaurant

4. North Italia - Madison

new

4.1

Excellent(102)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Booked 87 times today

Excellent food and service! Beautiful day in the patio!

A photo of Benvenuto's - Middleton restaurant

5. Benvenuto's - Middleton

3.6

Very Good(77)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Portions are generous! Have only tried pasta entrees but they are very good, especially the chicken tetrazzini. The Brussels sprouts appetizer was perfectly crispy. Minestrone soup tasted homemade with lots of veggies. Good value overall. The ambiance isn’t great—go for the food!

6. Bar Corallini

4.9

Exceptional(57)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Booked 40 times today

We loved the Eggplant fritters. They were so delicious. The pizza with pepperoni and pickles jalapeños is always good. Paired the eggplant fritters with the kale salad and I was amazed.

7. Villa Dolce

4.9

Exceptional(671)

$$$$

• Italian • Middleton

Booked 15 times today

All four of us thoroughly enjoyed our dinner. The pastas and pizzas were fantastic. The service was efficient had helpful. Even with a mix up in our reservation change they accommodated us in a friendly and professional manner. We will definitely be back.

A photo of Sugar River Pizza Company restaurant

8. Sugar River Pizza Company

4.7

Exceptional(492)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Booked 7 times today

Always a good experience at Sugar River. Good food, good beer, reasonably priced.

A photo of Draper Brother's Chophouse restaurant

9. Draper Brother's Chophouse

4.6

Exceptional(384)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Booked 14 times today

Excellent service and we greatly appreciate them accommodating a larger group reservation on a homecoming Saturday - 12 people. 10 out of 12 of us had excellent meals ranging from the Draper Steak to spaghetti and meatballs. The HOF skirt steak was undercooked and a poor cut of meat - but they took it off our bill with minimal comments from us. Service was excellent although it was near 2 hours to get our entrees after sitting down. Would recommend giving it a shot.

10. D’Vino

4.6

Exceptional(897)

$$$$

• Italian • Madison

Booked 7 times today

We love eating at D'Vino. Top notch service, delicious food (1/2 chicken and lasagna amazing!), pretty place, and quiet for conversations.

Best Italian Restaurants in Merrimac

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

14 restaurants available nearby

1. Sortino’s Italian Kitchen - Wisconsin Dells

2. Cento

3. Sarento's Italian Restaurant

4. North Italia - Madison

5. Benvenuto's - Middleton

6. Bar Corallini

7. Villa Dolce

8. Sugar River Pizza Company

9. Draper Brother's Chophouse

10. D’Vino

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable