11 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Fisher Island

A photo of North Italia – Miami (Mary Brickell) restaurant

1. North Italia – Miami (Mary Brickell)

4.5

$$$$

• Sicilian • Brickell

Booked 15 times today

North Italia – Miami (Mary Brickell) is a gem in the heart of Brickell, Miami, renowned for its exceptional Contemporary Italian cuisine. This vibrant restaurant prides itself on crafting authentic Italian dishes from scratch, using only the freshest seasonal ingredients. Diners rave about the "delicious, fresh food," with handmade pastas and inventive pizzas standing out as crowd favorites. The inviting atmosphere and "amazing service" contribute to an unforgettable dining experience. Whether indulging in the "superb Burrata and heirloom tomato salad" or savoring the "excellent Eggplant Parmesan," North Italia consistently delivers a taste of modern Italy, making it a must-visit destination for Italian food enthusiasts.

A photo of Fratelli La Bufala restaurant

2. Fratelli La Bufala

4.6

Exceptional(712)

$$$$

• Sicilian • South Beach

Booked 3 times today

Fratelli La Bufala offers an exceptional Mediterranean dining experience that is a true representation of authentic Italian cuisine in Miami Beach's vibrant South of 5th neighborhood. Renowned as Miami's first Neapolitan Pizzeria, this restaurant has been delighting patrons for 20 years with its "delicious diavola pizza and Mediterranean salad." Fratelli La Bufala stands out by sourcing high-quality ingredients from small local farms in Italy, ensuring that every dish, from their real buffalo mozzarella to homemade pasta, is "authentic" and "as to be in Italy." With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, it’s a must-visit for Italian cuisine lovers.

3. Seia - Miami

4.5

Awesome(46)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Brickell

Booked 24 times today

Seia Club is an invitation-only members’ community designed to cultivate meaningful connection through programming crafted around the pillars of culinary and culture. Named after Seia, the Roman goddess who watched over the sowing of seeds, the restaurant is rooted in the connection between land, culinary craft, and community.Join us for Aperitivo Hour - Monday through Friday from 5 PM to 7 PM. Walk-ins welcome! https://www.seiamiami.com/events/

A photo of Donna Mare Italian Chophouse restaurant

4. Donna Mare Italian Chophouse

4.4

Awesome(757)

$$$$

• Sicilian • South Beach

Booked 5 times today

Donna Mare Trattoria, nestled in the vibrant South Beach of Miami, offers an authentic Seafood dining experience that transports you to the romantic coastal regions of Italy. Renowned for its “outstanding seafood,” the restaurant serves dishes like the exquisite Branzino and delectable Tuna Tartare, both praised for their freshness and flavor. Guests rave about the “best linguine and clams ever” and the impeccable service that complements the culinary artistry. The ambiance, infused with the essence of Miami Beach, perfectly complements the exquisite food, making it a must-visit for Seafood enthusiasts. It's a place where every meal becomes a memorable feast.

5. Hosteria Romana

4.5

Awesome(224)

$$$$

• Sicilian • South Beach

Booked 8 times today

Hosteria Romana, located on the charming Espanola Way in South Beach, Miami Beach, delivers an exceptional Meat cuisine experience that is truly a cut above. Diners rave about the "extremely good food" and the "generous portions" that leave a lasting impression. The restaurant's commitment to authenticity shines through in every dish, with the fresh cut prosciutto being a standout favorite among patrons. Guests describe their meals as "unbelievably good," and the lively, fun atmosphere amplifies the dining experience, making it a destination where "Italians go for Italian." Whether you're a local or a visitor, Hosteria Romana promises a memorable culinary journey.

6. Bar Luca

4.6

Exceptional(89)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Mid-Beach

Booked 5 times today

Bar Luca, nestled in the heart of Mid-Beach, Miami Beach, is a beacon of authentic American cuisine with a delightful Italian flair. This charming neighborhood spot, located within the historic Alden Hotel, captivates diners with its "excellent food and cocktails" and a menu that celebrates the fusion of Italian-American specialties. Executive Chef Santo Agnello’s passion shines through in every dish, from perfectly cooked fresh pasta to the tantalizing creme brulee cheesecake. Guests rave about the "super attentive" service and the warm, inviting atmosphere that makes them feel at home. Bar Luca truly stands out as a "great neighborhood gem," promising a memorable dining experience for all.

A photo of Francesco Martucci restaurant

7. Francesco Martucci

4.4

Awesome(215)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Wynwood

Booked 8 times today

A journey from Caserta to Miami. Now open in Wynwood.Born in Caserta, Italy, Chef Francesco Martucci brings the legendary legacy of Pizzeria I Masanielli to Miami’s vibrant Wynwood neighborhood. Here, wood-fired tradition meets South Florida energy — the finest meticulously sourced Italian ingredients blended with local produce and bold Miami-inspired accents.Recognized as the World’s Best Pizzeria, Martucci was named No. 1 on 50 Top Pizza World 2025, No. 1 Pizzeria in Italy by 50 Top Pizza Italia for seven consecutive years (2019–2025), and made history as the first pizza restaurant ever to place in the Top 20 restaurants in the world. He has also been honored by Identità Golose 2025 and awarded the prestigious title of “Maestro della Pizza” by the American Food Bible.

A photo of Pelican Italian Restaurant in Miami Beach restaurant

8. Pelican Italian Restaurant in Miami Beach

4.0

Excellent(69)

$$$$

• Sicilian • South Beach

UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT-Indulge in the art of 'dolce far niente' as you embark on a culinary journey inspired by Italian cuisine, given a delightful modern twist. Savor our collection and homemade dishes served piping hot from our oven, or delve into salads crafted from the freshest, high-quality ingredients. As the sun gracefully sets, the Pelican Italian Restaurant becomes a culinary destination like no other. It seamlessly fuses the rich tapestry of Italian culinary traditions with the personal touch of our skilled chef. To complement this epicurean journey, our wine list takes center stage with labels from the North to the captivating South of Italy. For those who appreciate the finer things, we offer a collection of French Champagne to add that extra sparkle to your evening. At the Pelican, we believe in crafting not just meals but memories, and our commitment to the art of dining ensures that every visit is a cinematic experience for your palate.

A photo of North Italia - Dadeland restaurant

9. North Italia - Dadeland

4.5

Awesome(903)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Kendall

Booked 7 times today

North Italia - Dadeland offers an exquisite journey into Contemporary Italian cuisine, right in the heart of Kendall, Miami. The restaurant is celebrated for its authentic Italian dishes made from scratch, featuring handmade pastas and pizzas that embody "inventive flavors" and "seasonal ingredients." Diners rave about the "exceptional menu" crafted by the chef, ensuring a delightful experience for every palate. Highly praised for its "amazing food" and "5-star service," North Italia creates a vibrant atmosphere that is both chic and family-friendly. With a commitment to fresh flavors and meticulously handcrafted dishes, North Italia truly stands out as a gem in contemporary Italian dining.

A photo of Fratelli By Jholano's restaurant

10. Fratelli By Jholano's

4.0

Excellent(141)

$$$$

• Sicilian • South Miami

Booked 1 time today

Where Italian roots blend seamlessly with Miami’s cultural flavor. Fratelli by Jholano’s is a family-owned restaurant bringing together the heart of Italian cuisine with the vibrant energy of Miami. Our menu reimagines traditional recipes with fresh local influences, offering everything from comforting classics to bold new creations. Whether you’re craving pasta, seafood, or small plates, every dish is crafted with care to create a dining experience that feels both timeless and uniquely Miami.

Best Sicilian Restaurants in Fisher Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

11 restaurants available nearby

1. North Italia – Miami (Mary Brickell)

2. Fratelli La Bufala

3. Seia - Miami

4. Donna Mare Italian Chophouse

5. Hosteria Romana

6. Bar Luca

7. Francesco Martucci

8. Pelican Italian Restaurant in Miami Beach

9. North Italia - Dadeland

10. Fratelli By Jholano's

Explore OpenTable