Best Authentic Restaurants in Fire Island

The food was delicious. And the service was great, very polite staff. Looking forward to dining here again soon

We had an absolutely wonderful experience our waitress Cassandra was incredible. She couldn’t have been more professional and nicer. We were really impressed by her knowledge of the food and her general waitressing skills. My husband rated his steak at 10 out of 10, the fish was delicious, and the chocolate soufflé was out of this world. And the truffle pasta tableside was just incredible. If you’re going to this restaurant, expect to spend a lot of money but to have a wonderful experience with fantastic food and wonderful wait staff

We were a group of 20. Staff was amazing in getting our orders in correctly (due to the volume of the music and conversations). I was nervous at first and they killed it with accuracy and attention to our group was on point. Kudos to the staff!

We loveee John’s service and attentiveness, but the icing on the cake is Emily. When she visits our table to check up on us it feels so genuine. She’s a gem. The staff feed off of her positive energy. Always a great experience when John and Emily are there. Can’t wait to go back!!!

I can’t believe I used to drive by this place all the time always saying that I wanna stop here and eat and I never have in many many years, but this was an absolute amazing find. I will definitely be back. The food was amazing. The staff were all friendly and the best of all it was not a loud restaurant.