Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Lake Mary

From Pittsburgh, visit Tibby’s every time we visit the area and always great food and service. First time visiting during Sun brunch and have to say the food, drinks, service, and vibe were outstanding. Keep up the great job, team!

We enjoy dining here because the food and experience are always consistently excellent. Our favorites: starting with the lavas bread with baba ghanoush and yogurt tzatziki. We also enjoy the Lentil Soup, which we share. For entrees my dining partner’s favorite is the Grilled Chicken Sis Kebap with Rice Pilaf. The Chicken Sauté with Lemon Sauce is my absolute favorite! It’s always delicious. I also choose the Rice Pilaf, as my side, (so flavorful) and my companion typically orders the baklava for dessert, with Turkish coffee. It’s a lot of food, but strategic, because we enjoy it so much we enjoy having extra to take home. We also like bringing our backgammon game and playing a round before the food comes out. It’s a fun setting for it because of the ancient history of the game in Turkish culture. The service is excellent and I appreciate how the staff and John, the manager, are careful to ensure the order avoids specific food allergens. It is aways a pleasant and smooth dining experience.

Still and forever is one of my favorite places in Winter Park to go to. The service, the atmosphere, and the food are all amazing.

We visited the Pinery because of Magical Dining month. I had the fried green tomatoes and the shrimp and grits. My wife had the brie appetizer and the beef short rib. The food was excellent. The service was top notch too - thank you Alex! We will be back again!

We did magical dining. The grilled meatloaf was delicious, the Caesar salad was enough for 3 people. Our server was wonderful and very helpful.