9 Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Paia

9 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Makawao Public House restaurant

1. Makawao Public House

4.7

Exceptional(469)

$$$$

• Gastro Pub • Makawao

Booked 13 times today

I sent all my clients to this restaurant because I can always trust. They’re going to have an amazing experience.

2. Mauka Makai

4.3

Awesome(371)

$$$$

• Hawaii Regional Cuisine • Kaanapali

Booked 11 times today

Wonderful!! Service and food were great after a long day waiting for our room....

A photo of The Pour House Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar restaurant

3. The Pour House Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar

4.4

Awesome(2406)

$$$$

• Italian • Kapalua

Booked 7 times today

Excellent family run restaurant. A must do dining option when in West Maui

A photo of Maui Brewing Co. - Ka’anapali restaurant

4. Maui Brewing Co. - Ka’anapali

4.3

Awesome(707)

$$$$

• Brewery • Kaanapali

Booked 63 times today

Light years better than your average brewery restaurant. Food and service was amazing!

5. Gather on Maui

4.6

Exceptional(1733)

$$$$

• International • Wailea

Booked 35 times today

Our waitress Maria was very attentive and made wonderful suggestions. The Gather Mai Tai was the best ever. The Calamari was as beautiful as it was delicious. Watching the sunset was a highlight.

A photo of Brigit & Bernard's Garden Cafe restaurant

6. Brigit & Bernard's Garden Cafe

4.7

Exceptional(282)

$$$$

• German • Kahului

Booked 4 times today

Great authentic Northern European food and very friendly staff. Will definitely be coming back here! Highly recommend!

A photo of Teppan-Yaki Dan - Sheraton Maui restaurant

7. Teppan-Yaki Dan - Sheraton Maui

4.0

Excellent(702)

$$$$

• Hibachi • Kaanapali

Booked 8 times today

The food, experience, and service were great! The standout for me is my husband is a vegetarian. They were accommodating to ensure little to no cross contamination and that he had sufficient food/options.

A photo of the Hideaway by Aloha prime restaurant

8. the Hideaway by Aloha prime

4.5

Awesome(91)

$$$$

• Prime Rib • Kīhei

Booked 8 times today

Lovely service and great food. Our server was attentive without being intrusive.

A photo of Mulligans on the Blue restaurant

9. Mulligans on the Blue

4.5

Awesome(994)

$$$$

• American • Wailea

Booked 1 time today

Open table booked us in for Saturday night but when we arrived we found out that Mulligans was closed for dinner. The manager was very sympathetic and said if we came back on Sunday our first drink would be free along with the live band. Subsequently booked in for Sunday night and the staff were all very attentive. Great band and as I was driving I was delighted that I managed to get Guinness zero. The prawn starter we both had was delicious and I enjoyed my sausage, peas and mash. My wife’s fish tacos were however disappointing. Happy to recommend particularly on a live music night.

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Paia

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

9 restaurants available nearby

1. Makawao Public House

2. Mauka Makai

3. The Pour House Italian Kitchen and Wine Bar

4. Maui Brewing Co. - Ka’anapali

5. Gather on Maui

6. Brigit & Bernard's Garden Cafe

7. Teppan-Yaki Dan - Sheraton Maui

8. the Hideaway by Aloha prime

9. Mulligans on the Blue

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable