Best Hot Spot Restaurants in Fenwick Island

This is an outstanding restaurant. The food, the service and ambience is Phenomenal.

As a vacation destination, Cape May has plenty of drinking establishments, from swanky venues and hipster havens to beach bars and local dives. Tucked in one of Cape May’s leading landmarks, the renovated 1879 Congress Hall Hotel, we decided on dinner at the Blue Pig Tavern, which derives from a gambling parlor in the mid-1800s. A reservation was easily made via Open Table. Upon arrival as first timers, my partner and I were greeted at the host station and got our cozy table in a large glassed-in patio area. The restaurant was lively and welcoming. It was clearly a family-friendly spot, which showed in the higher noise level and the number of tables filled with multigenerational groups. Their menu is New American, from filet mignon and shrimp cocktail to legendary burgers, including the Beach Plum Farm Burger. They get a lot of its produce from its own nearby farm. As an appetizer, we decided on the Crispy Calamari and Baked Mac and Cheese. Our entree consisted of Rigatoni Bolognese and Chicken Pot Pie. Complimentary warm bread sprinkled with salt and chives accompanied by soft honey butter started our meal. Every dish hit the mark: flavorful, fresh, and well-executed. The portions were generous. Despite being very busy, the service was excellent from start to finish. The staff was attentive, friendly, and especially helpful; our server was Eugene. Overall, this establishment delivered a memorable dining experience.

Best dinners ever! Great food, beautiful environment. Great service.

We were celebrating our anniversary and had a wonderful meal! I had the pork chop and my wife had the seared tuna. Both were outstanding. Cooked perfectly and the accompaniments were delicious. We loved the mix of flavors and creativity. Service was friendly and efficient. We also got the salted blondie dessert, it was delicious, the combination of chocolate and peanut butter was wonderful. The complimentary champagne to celebrate our anniversary was appreciated as well! One Coastal is a gem! We’ll be back again!

Excellent as always!! Rachel, the bartender, is always helpful answering questions on different drinks and specials.