Restaurants near Judge J. C. Kerwin House

We loved our first visit to Rye. So many great choices we had a hard time deciding. We got the maple bacon shrimp and French onion soup for starters and the filet and wagyu beef burger for dinner. Everything was beautifully plated, hot and tasted wonderful. It was our anniversary and we got a cute note when we arrived and a dessert to share. That was a fun surprise. Oh yeah, the drinks were great too. Nice selection of alcohol as well. We’ll be back.

Food and service were amazing! Staff members at the bar and our table were very friendly!

Tonight was our first time at Fratellos. My wife and I have always heard great things about it, so we decided to give it a try for our 25th wedding anniversary. We were definitely not disappointed. The restaurant has a great vibe and the ambiance was excellent. We were early enough to have a great view of the water, but also late enough to see the dark night creep in and the candlelight intensify. It’s a small space and it gets a bit loud, especially when there are large tables of people nearby, but it didn’t deter our dinner conversation in the least. An add-on that they provide is a table topped with beautiful rose pedals, which I couldn’t pass up for this occasion. It added a wonderful touch to the already beautiful atmosphere. The food and staff were both outstanding. The prime ribeye was one of the best steaks that I’ve ever had, perfectly done and extremely tender. Everything was cooked to perfection and delicious. Thank you Fratellos staff for making our milestone anniversary so special and memorable!

Absolutely love this place and our kids loved this experience.

As always the food and service were amazing. My beloved sea bass is off the menu, but the swordfish was a perfect choice! The mushroom risotto also never disappoints.