Restaurants near The Fishpond Cottage

Absolutely fantastic! Merriman’s was hands down one of the highlights of our trip to Maui! The food, atmosphere, spectacular ocean views, and incredible service made this such a memorable experience. The chow fun noodles are TO DIE FOR! Seriously, do not skip them! Everything we ordered was delicious, including the filet, lamb chops, macadamia nut-crusted fish, and crème brûlée. Every single dish was amazing, and we couldn't have been happier with our meal. Our server, Jasmine, was absolutely wonderful! She went above and beyond to make our experience special. It was my friend's birthday, and they even had a birthday message printed on the menu for her. Such a thoughtful, personal touch that made the evening even more memorable! The atmosphere was beautiful, and the ocean views were absolutely spectacular. Watching the sunset while enjoying incredible food and outstanding service was the perfect way to celebrate. Merriman’s exceeded every expectation! If you're visiting Maui, this is a MUST-DO. The food is phenomenal, the views are breathtaking, and Jasmine made the entire experience unforgettable. We would go back in a heartbeat!

Best fish ever! Service is fantastic. The staff is very friendly and efficient. Beautiful sunsets and the best ambiance

Plates were clean after each of the eight people in our party finished their meal. Each dish was raved about and the whitefish with lobster sauce special was phenomenal. Our server was attentive and kind. Overall we had a wonderful experience.

I have been lucky to come to Leilani’s the past few years to celebrate my birthday while we are in Maui and always have an amazing experience! Sasha was our server. She was very attentive and personable. 10/10. We ordered the ahi tuna, parmesan crusted and herb roasted fish dishes which were AMAZING! All of us could have licked our plates. The entertainment on Wednesday night was fantastic. We always come for the view and it never fails us. Highly recommend coming to Leilani’s if you are visiting Maui!

Everything was perfect from start to finish. Our service was amazing. We ordered dishes to share and they were delivered at intervals that neither pushed us or kept us waiting at any time. We had the deviled eggs w/lobster, the poke trio, and finished with the fish tacos. All delicious! My husband had the Mai Tai, which he loved, especially the foam topping! I had a margarita, which was very good too. Would definitely recommend this fun and inviting restaurant!