Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Martha's Vineyard

View all

Best Contemporary American Restaurants in Martha's Vineyard

Popular restaurants in New England

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New England

Casa Caña
(99)
$$$$
Latin / Spanish | Allston
Pammy's
(686)
$$$$
American | Cambridge
Little Donkey
(896)
$$$$
Tapas / Small Plates | Cambridge
Article 24
(199)
$$$$
American | Brighton
Longfellow
(301)
$$$$
American | Cambridge
View all New England restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Martha's Vineyard restaurants

  • Restaurant List

Martha's Vineyard Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Martha's Vineyard restaurants

Martha's Vineyard Restaurants

L'ETOILE RESTAURANT
L'ETOILE RESTAURANT
(293)
$$$$
French | Martha's Vineyard, Cape Cod and the Islands

We always plan a special dinner at L'etoile when back on the Vineyard. This years' dinner, like those previously (including those at the Charlotte Inn),was superb. The atmosphere is a little more relaxed that previously but the kitchen still keeps turning out very upscale results. I started with the warm spinach salad with shaved egg yolk, bacon bits and a very mild lemony-sweet dressing. My wife had the asparagus and sweet pea soup with a dollop of poached lobster and truffle butter -- seasonal and delicious. My wife and I both had the halibut -- absolutely delicious. Perfectly prepared (not at all dry) with mixed seasonal island vegetables and a sauce that still leaves my mouth watering -- perfect blend of tomato with lemon accent. Spaghetti squash with a hint of cinnamon was a very nice accompaniment. Finish with house made caramel sea salt ice cream and a cappuccino -- perfect dinner. The service was exceptional -- friendly, very attentive but not at all overbearing. We were warmly welcomed and treated like regulars even though that is not the case. It's great that some things at the Vineyard don't change. More

OpenTable Diner -
Chilmark Tavern
Chilmark Tavern
(83)
$$$$
American | Martha's Vineyard, Cape Cod and the Islands

Simply the best. More

OpenTable Diner -
Garde East
Garde East
(302)
$$$$
Seafood | Martha's Vineyard, Cape Cod and the Islands

Excellent food and location. Servers although attentive are not as trained for the type of restaurant. More

OpenTable Diner -
Woods at Lambert’s Cove Inn
Woods at Lambert’s Cove Inn
(333)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Martha's Vineyard, Cape Cod and the Islands

Loved the place! We had Nick for our waiter, he was excellent. The menu has something for everyone! I highly recommend the rib eye. More

OpenTable Diner -
Farm Neck Cafe
Farm Neck Cafe
(86)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Martha's Vineyard, Cape Cod and the Islands

The atmosphere is nice and the food is very good. The menu is somewhat limited though. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sharky's Edgartown
Sharky's Edgartown
Reviews Coming Soon
Mexican | Martha's Vineyard, Cape Cod and the Islands

Sharky's Cantina in Edgartown is about as family and budget friendly as it comes. With 50 menu items all priced under $10, you and the kids can all eat at a modest cost. When you want to be a bit more extravagant, there are plenty of choices for that too, such as the super quesadilla plato that is stuffed with your choice of protein, lots of cheese, guacamole, sour cream and housemade salsa. The super grandiose baked burrito plato is equally as hefty.

If spicy is your thing, give the jalapeno crusted mozzarella sticks or the killaÕ quansoo quesadilla plato a try. The SharkyÕs Cantina house made habanero-pineapple-mango-cilantro salsa that comes with this quesadilla definitely bites back. Another popular favorite at SharkyÕs Cantina is the range of burgers, each made with six ounces of 100% grass fed, free range, antibiotic and growth hormone free beef.

More

Discover Martha's Vineyard

In Martha's Vineyard, the 57th largest island in the U.S., you will find yourself surrounded by elegant accommodations and a vast array of restaurants. Visitors and locals have their choice of everything from casual to fine dining in this luxurious yet laid-back location. Popular foods include homestyle dishes that are popular in the area such as quahog chowder, fish cakes, and fries, all served with your favorite beverage. You can also try out flatbread sandwiches and unique pizza flavors. You can always find an establishment or two that serves some of the best seafood dishes along the East Coast including lobster rolls, spicy tuna rolls, and clam chowder.

Discover Martha's Vineyard

In Martha's Vineyard, the 57th largest island in the U.S., you will find yourself surrounded by elegant accommodations and a vast array of restaurants. Visitors and locals have their choice of everything from casual to fine dining in this luxurious yet laid-back location. Popular foods include homestyle dishes that are popular in the area such as quahog chowder, fish cakes, and fries, all served with your favorite beverage. You can also try out flatbread sandwiches and unique pizza flavors. You can always find an establishment or two that serves some of the best seafood dishes along the East Coast including lobster rolls, spicy tuna rolls, and clam chowder.