Blue Steel Pizza Company
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Great dinner and Seth was a great server.
Wow, great ambience and excellent service and food
Ashley was extremely kind and attentive. We were greeted promptly and throughout the night Ashley performed a healthy number (not too much nor too little) of table touches. As someone who works in the industry I greatly appreciate it when a server knows what they are doing. The food was excellent, and the cocktails were delightful. I will be visiting again!
Great first experience, food was amazing, service was impeccable. Will definitely come back again
Everything is amazing. Their cocktails are beautiful and a must have. The pizza is insanely good and so are the small plates. This is a must visit restaurant!
Great experience overall. Came on a Saturday afternoon for lunch and the food was amazing. You can tell this is a popular place in town by how quickly it filled up. Pretty adequate seating (socially distanced for Covid) but parking is tough.
The food was delicious. I had the ricotta and bacon pizza, at the waiters suggestion, and was not disappointed. They make a mean cocktail as well!
Will def be back! Thanks
The pizza here is incredible, the style is unlike anything you can get in this area, and the way they craft the toppings is so delicious. This is where we take anyone visiting because it's always a hit. Try the cola wings and supreme pie, but I would recommend literally anything on their menu.
The food was yummy I would go back here
This is my absolute favorite restaurant. I love the atmosphere, the drinks and the food! The menu always has new foods to try and everything I’ve tried has been so delicious! I don’t go out to eat much now but when I do, I go to blue steel!
Everything was wonderful! Would love to go there again!
Great Atmosphere. Great service. And 5 star flavors and creativity with food!
Blue Steel Pizza is our new favorite place!!! We discovered in New Years Eve this year and we were blown away! The food quality is from another planet!!! It is the most gourmet pizzeria I have ever been to for sure! The staff is super nice, they have great options for vegetarians, and the drinks are AMAZING!!! Obsessed with this place and the food!!! I cannot recommend it enough!!!! <3
Great cocktails, food and amazing service
Love this place been twice, making it one of my go to!
Our waitress was awesome, the ambiance was awesome and so was the music. Will definitely go again.
Great Food, Great Service and comfortable dining experience
Great food, excellent and attentive service, made for a wonderful experience. Perfect for date night!!
Everything was awesome
Loved it! Great place
Great time with friends at Blue Steel- server and manger were great. Food was delicious! Definitely going to come back.
We had a great time at Blue Steel! It was our first time there and our server Alex was amazing! She was very knowledgeable about all of menu items and the different ingredients they use! It was so much fun to try a bunch of specialty drinks that were outside of our comfort zone!
& THE PIZZA WAS THE BOMB!!! 😍😍😍
I'm torn on the stars... I hate to give a lower star.
I would honestly rate this between 3 1/2 stars to 4.
Wanted to try a new place for pizza and saw Blue Steel pizza. Looking at the location I realize it's at the location of the old Wooden Spoon restaurant.
We started out with the Coca Cola wings which had great flavor, nice and crispy but they are on the smaller side but were very good. Home made ranch was good also.
Ordered the Classic pizza, A Detroit style deep dish. Was surprised at how small it was, especially for the price and to be shared. It's a personal size ( literally I could eat the whole thing by myself). If you can eat 2/3 slices of a regular pizza, order your own. The crust was light and airy, the sauce was good. I did like the brick cheese the best.
The burger was pretty good. Cooked perfect. Fries were good also.
The sweet potato flan was the BOMB... the best twist on flan I have ever tasted ... I would give that a 10!! Definitely order it.
The tiramisu was delicious also, not your typical tiramisu though.
*if you have a child that's picky with food...not a very kid friendly menu.
The restaurant itself was very pretty. This is more of a date night or group of adults place.
Service was phenomenal !! 5 stars for service.
Great service! Outstanding Food! Gotta go with the PORK CUTLET SANDWICH..
It’s not often that I’m more tempted to eat other items off the menu of a ‘pizza restaurant’. But this place you have to do both...
From the unique take on chicken wings to the homemade pasta to the (of course) fabulous Chicago style deep dish pizza - it’s a tour well worth taking!
I went here on a date night this past weekend and sat at the high top table by the bar. Where we sat was perfect, I personally didn't mind having our own little corner, I almost forgot there were tables next to us, the restaurant did well by the social distance guidelines. We had the Cola Wings and Tuna Tostada for appetizers after reading other people rave about them and they did live up to our expectations. For drinks we had the DTour and the New Motto, definitely recommend. For dinner we had the Peperoni and the Supreme, also recommend. Our waitress was great and not too overbearing. Overall, the ambience was great and perfect for a well needed date night.
Tuna appetizer small plate very good. pizza could of cooked a little longer. Followed CDC guidelines for COVID.
Great food and service - crispy cola wings were delicious!
A friend recommended this place and we decided to try it. We started with the béchamel fries which were very good. The tuna tartare was also fresh and very good. We got the duck ramen and the pizza which were both good.
Will be coming back and trying different things. We really liked the ambiance. The cocktails were delicious.
It was our 2nd visi
Pizza and service and corner table were all outstanding! Can’t wait to go back! A little more light is my only recommendation. Staff from entry to departure were all excellent.
Everything about BlueSteel Pizza was top-notch—amazing craft cocktails served by a knowledgable staff, and some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We’ll be back!
Food and drinks are sooooo good. We keep coming back for more!!!
Great place for small plates drinks and a rarity in NJ Detroit style pizza.
We’ve been waiting to try Blue Steel and it did not disappoint!! Our meal was amazing and our server Kenny made us feel right at home in this crazy world we are living in. We ordered 3 small plates to start and our only regret was not doubling that order as our kids ate 1/2 of them. It was our first time trying Detroit-style pizza and it was delicious! Hands down one of the best meals and cocktails we’ve had recently and we can’t wait to go back!
Food and drinks were delicious and the service was excellent! Definitely coming back.
This restaurant is a neighborhood gem. I commend them for opening during a world crisis. I’ve been in the restaurant business over 25 years and I know when something feels great and this place is going to be a NJ great place.
The chef is very talented, the staff is beyond hospitable and friendly. The bartender is the BOOM! I asked for a Negroni and the bartender sent two different Gins for me to taste as a profile matching for my cocktail. Who does that “they did” WOW.
I hope they continue that old school style of guest relations and become a robust business.
Oh the FOOD. The pizza “ABSOLUTELY SICK” it was delicious
Port Milanese amazing. The pork was so fresh and the breadcrumbs were light and tasty.
The pasta, excellent.
This place is a winner
Great service, drinks were delicious and the pizza was very unique and tasty. Would definitely go back!
This place is amazing. Classy ambiance, delicious food, & friendly service...The flavors of the food are savory, & the cocktails are outstanding. Highly recommend for a romantic date night or an upscale night out with friends or family.
Food and drinks were on point! Will definitely go back!
Nothing negative say! Great food, great experience!
Blue Steel Pizza Company offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (973) 678-1873.
Blue Steel Pizza Company is rated 4.8 stars by 68 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.