Located in the heart of Garden City, our indoor and outdoor seating areas are ideal for a night out on the town. Using the best quality, freshest ingredients, Calogero’s Italian Restaurant delivers delectable, authentic Italian dishes.
With over 75 fine wines in our tremendous cellar, there’s something for everyone from anywhere in the world.
From our spacious dining room to our private party room, our staff goes above and beyond to make you feel at home.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
pan fried, lightly breaded, pomodoro sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, fresh cavatelli
watermelon, feta cheese, red onions, mint balsamic vinaigrette
first time eating there everything was delicious definitely going back
Really good food.
The food and service were the reasons we will definitely be back :)
Love it here! I keep going back for more. The food and atmosphere is great.
Our waitress, Sarai, was very pleasant and attentive. The food was delicious. We’re definitely going back soon!
All and all we always have an amazing time! Staff is amazing
very good food friendly service. reasonably priced. excellent expresso martinis
Always a great meal, excellent service and terrific ambiance.
VERY GOOD FOOD; GOOD SERVICE RELAXING EVENING; NICE SELECTIONS ON MENU
Ate out back in the tent at a table for 2. Food was awesome & service was great. Food was prepared exactly as we asked for it to be & waiter was very attentive!
Metal chair not so comfortable & very crooked/sloped sidewalk makes it a bit hard to get in if you’re handicapped, but overall an excellent restaurant that I I would highly recommend!
Went for Mother’s Day and they did a special Mother’s Day menu that I didn’t know about but I think it was a pretty good deal. The food was great and the service was great as well. Will definitely be back.
The was our first visit and we were so pleased with everything from the service to the food to the ambiance. We will be back!
Food is always outstanding. Service is consistently excellent. Love Calageros. Never disappoints.
I always love Calogero’s. The food is excellent, all the time! I’ve gotten catering from them before also, and usually quality suffers a little with large quantities, but not here. They have a massive outdoor tent with tables spaced apart nicely and heaters. Its beautifully decorated. We felt very comfortable eating here. The workers are very attentive and do a great job. I highly recommend for dining and catering!
I love this place. It never disappoints.
The service and food were outstanding. The atmosphere is nice; nothing very special. Would definitely go back!
The food and atmosphere was great. The only thing that bothered me - two people in my party substituted one type of pasta with another and they didn’t tell us there’s an up charge. They listed all the options so it was unclear. Not right in my opinion.
The baked clams were very pedestrian. The scallops were sandy. I felt like I was chewing grit and I sent it back. The salmon was very good.
Food and the service was excellent. Highly recommend
Hadn't been here in a very long time. Was not disappointed. Food was very good. Although pretty crowded, tables were adequately spaced. Will definitely be back.
We had a 7:30 reservation. We did not get seated until 8;00. With the Covid restrictions, there was no where to wait and we couldn’t get a drink to pass the time. When we were finally seated, we complained about the 30 minute wait. We were told that they were busy and did not apologize. With social distancing, management should figure out a waiting area if they cannot honor their reservation in a timely manner.
Outdoor space is uncomfortable
The veal was cold, frozen spinach, frozen veal smothered with cheese
Enjoyable dinner for 6 in their outdoor tent — delicious food and drinks. Unfortunately, a screaming child, not attended to by his parents, ruined the experience. We couldn’t wait to leave.
Excellent menu, generous portions, fine food, only negative is bad acoustics, high noise level.
I always go in thinking I know what to order until I see the specials menu. Sometimes it’s difficult to decide but never disappointed. Randy was our server and was excellent as was the food. I highly recommend this restaurant and look forward to my next visit.
Wonderful Italian restaurant. Nice ambience inside. Ample seating outside for those who worry about social distancing.
Always great food and service
The Food is always great. We decided to get dessert this time though and we were a little disappointed. The apple crumble came out ice cold with no whipped cream or ice cream and the cappuccino was very bitter. The main course was delicious though.
Food and service were excellent!
Love Calogero’s. Our favorite go to local place
Great service and food. The dividers work well to accommodate social distancing.
First time dining there - and will definitely return! Restaurant took COVID precautions seriously. Although fully vaccinated, dining with my 88 year old mom still a concern. Waiters was so on point and sweet. Food was delicious!! We were really impressed by the entire experience.
Love this place. Food is always consistent as well as service
Great food. Great service. Nice place. Definitely going back.
Amazing, had reservations and were taken care as soon as we walked in. The service was amazing and the food was outstanding!!! First time and will not be my last. Loved the energy as well. Great for girls night or even a date night
It was delicious! Chicken Frances is my favorite and that’s why I went!
Amazing restaurant that has quickly become our favorite local Italian spot. Amazing pizzas, phenomenal lasagna, pork chops done perfect, and everything else in between. Always great service and we never leave feeling as if anything is off. They are always on point and they are always consistent. Thank you for having great food, friendly service, and a relaxing and elegant ambiance.
Great food and service. Outdoor tent safe and warm
Made for an excellent Valentines Day dinner. My date and I enjoyed it very much.
We went for Valentine’s Day and it was really good! They had a pre-fixed menu for the night and it had a lot of options!! The service was excellent and the food was fantastic!
You can order delivery directly from Calogero's using the Order Online button. Calogero's also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 294-2922.
Calogero's is rated 4.7 stars by 103 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.