Liberty Prime Steakhouse
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Waitstaff wear masks
Chickpea mélange, fingerling potatoes, lemon oil
Creamed / Sauteed Spinach
I've been eying this steakhouse for quite some time now and finally decided to try it out to celebrate my engagement. From the point we walked in, to the point we left, there was nothing short of amazing. The food was beautifully presented and flavorful. Drinks were delicious and tasty. The service was outstanding as well! Amazing all around and we will definitely be back!
Beautiful restaurant, great ambiance and service but the food... must say we were quite underwhelmed. Appetizers like the octopus and the tuna tartare were good. However the main courses left a lot to be desired. The steak, while cooked perfectly, came to the table cold at room temperature. The sides were not good, especially the truffle mac and cheese (Mushy noodles and just very bland). Desserts were okay (Chocolate cake was decent, coconut creme brulee was only "coconut" because they put flakes at the bottom). Probably wouldn't dine here again. Can't recommend to others unless the food improves. NYC Overpriced but not meeting those expectations with what was being served.
The good is amazing. The staff is always pleasant. Couldn't say enough good things about Liberty Prime.
I took my boyfriend here for the first time for his birthday and it was excellent. The steaks were perfectly seasoned and cooked just to our liking . Our server and the staff were very kind and accommodating. Our server brought out the dessert with a candle and wrote on the plate wishing my boyfriend a happy bday as well as two complimentary glasses of champagne for a toast. We were able to take some great pictures and made memories that I will cherish forever . So thank you for a wonderful night and dinner , we will be back .
Celebrating a birthday! The food was excellent quality! The waiter gave us outstanding service!
This was not my first time at Liberty Prime but it will be my last, sorry to say.
The waiter constantly stopped by the table and rushed us through the meal. Once we ordered the apps and then entrees, the food seemed to come in 5 minutes, which just felt odd.
None of the food remotely justified the price, most especially the filet. It was completely average and lacked taste. Most especially for the money….
I had notified the hostess that there was a birthday in our party and was told they could do something nice. At the end of the meal, they simply brought the check. At which point I simply paid and left.
I would not recommend this restaurant, which is disappointing to say. NYC prices with subpar food and service.
For Mother’s Day.brunch.
The quiche was spongy and green. My wife did not care for it
The service and food was excellent. Our waiter gave some great recommendations on the best items on the menu. Will definitely come back.
Great fancy restaurant, amazing food, upscale prices, lovely interior decor, and good service.
KC for two can't be beat, potatoes au gratin, and onion rings. : )
The food was so good and the waiter made great recommendations. Definitely planning to go back soon!
The Food was delicious! The staff was very attentive even when I had to call on the phone to reschedule the timing they were understanding and helpful!
Service and ambiance was outstanding. The food left me with something to be desired.
Apps and soup was ok but when you order a medium rare steak and receive a medium well for the price we paid. Big thumbs down!
Really inconsistent and uneven throughout the meal. The steak itself was fairly good, but was badly overcooked, a medium-rare hitting what many would call medium-well, and the sear turning into more of a char at points, lending a bitter, burnt taste to a very good cut of meat. For drinks, a supposed Passion Fruit Mojito was glorified lime juice with ice and was practically undrinkable. Bread was sweet and too soft and tasted like a store-bought roll. An appetizer which was said to come with goat cheese had no cheese to be found, and supposed cheddar mashed potatoes were similarly lacking in our delectable orange friend. The meal was frankly unacceptable for the price.
Wonderful waiter, fantastic food and presentation.
The food was amazing. Our waiter Pablo was amazing. Everyone was nice and attentive.
A little pricey and you have to order sides.
The key lime pie was super tart—not sweet at all and you definitely had to dip it in the raspberry sauce... but I enjoyed it.
The crab cake appetizer was very fresh and absolutely delicious—😍
Excilent service throughout our whole time. Server was great ! Food great! Service great! Going again !
We had double rib steak a few nights ago. The quality of the steak was terrible, it didnt taste fresh and tough to eat. Definitely not the best steak house we have been to.
Fantastic! I can't wait to come back again. Food was delicious!
This place is amazeballs! We arrived early and grabbed a drink at their bar next door. The bartenders were incredibly friendly. I had Johnny Walker Blue. I asked for a single and the pour was more of a triple. So needless to say I was feeling good for dinner. As time got closer to our reservation, we walked over to the main restaurant. We were promptly seated upstairs overlooking the main floor. We already knew what we wanted: the wedge salad, tomahawk and mashed potatoes. When they say for two, they mean it. I normally can finish of a tomahawk and the sides by myself. Not this bad boy, my wife and I took home about a third of the steak and half of the potatoes. We will be back to try their other steaks and sides, very soon. Thanks to everyone at Liberty Prime for a great evening!
Food and ambience was just perfect. I would definitely recommend to family.
Feel safe during lunch time.
Would have lunch menu.
Loved the food. I was NOT disappointed at all. The staff was amazing and professional. I would most def recommend.
I was looking for a place to have dinner in Jersey City, and am so glad that I found Liberty Prime on Open Table. First of all, the restaurant is absolutely gorgeous. The tables were all nicely spread apart, so I felt completely safe. I started with the lobster bisque - which was out of this world. I then had the mahi mahi with a red pepper risotto - simply amazing. I finished with the banana bread pudding, which was delicious. My server Adrian and the rest of the staff were all fantastic. Terrific dining option in Jersey City.
We went for my boyfriend’s birthday dinner and everything was amazing! The seabass and ribeye were our entrees. We also had tuna tartare, grilled octopus, lobster mac, and creamed spinach. Best seabass I ever had! We will definitely come back.
The service was awesome and glad to have a local place for great steak and seafood.
Liberty Prime never fails us.. the best filet mignon !
Delicious food and even better service!
My husband and I ordered the Tomahawk steak for two. $140.00, the taste was good but the fat was overkill! The service and ambiance were outstanding though and the drinks were delicious! Would still go again
We booked Valentine's Day dinner at Liberty Steakhouse in Jersey City. We arrived at the time of our reservation (6pm) and were seated in a back corner away from most of the other diners. We asked the staff to send over our waiter multiple times and by 6:30 our waiter had not come to our table so we got up and left. They didn't even bring water over in 30 minutes for a restaurant that's supposed to have no more than 25% capacity...
I have been here many times before and unfortunately tonight was one of the worst experiences I’ve had. Food and service subpar at best. Very disappointing to say the least. I will not be returning.
Very good and great service.
My experience was great!
The whole experience was amazing. It was a birthday celebration. The waitress was excellent in explaining the dishes and recommending new items. Food was cooked as requested and tasted excellent. The appetizer was beef with brie more than amazing.
after dinner they surprised us with a slice of cheese cake and a candle for the birthday person.
I always wanted to dine at this restaurant since I moved to jersey, I went on a first date and chose this restaurant and that was the best idea. We had a great time and the food was delicious. We will be back the eat again.
First time here and I was completely blown away by the service and food. Nadia our server was so attentive and accommodating. We never had to ask for one refill! We celebrated my boyfriend’s birthday here and it was the perfect gothic ambiance. The NY style cheesecake was to die for. The manager on duty gave us a quick tour of the space after as well. We will definitely be back :)
The food here was outstanding for the price and our server was very attentive! Best bread ive ever had! Perfect birthday dinner date night.
Everything was amazing, I had no complaints. I’m looking forward to going back soon.
This restaurant was a first time for me and I loved it! From the service to the food and drinks, it was wonderful! The only con I would have to say is that the octopus we ordered was a little bit over cooked, but otherwise everything else was top notch.
Liberty Prime Steakhouse is rated 4.3 stars by 509 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.