Prodigy Burger & Bar - Carmel

3.9

20 Reviews

$30 and under

Burgers

Top Tags:

Prodigy is a craft burger bar that specializes in paying homage to the greats of the past who were prodigies of their own time! Come try our delicious craft burgers, cocktails, and beers!

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.

Is this your restaurant?

Claim this listing

Order delivery or takeout

Options

Order online

Additional information

Dining style
Casual Dining
Cuisines
Burgers, American
Phone number
(317) 569-9996
Dress code
Casual Dress

Location
14490 Clay Terrace Blvd, Carmel, IN 46032-3623
Neighborhood
Carmel / Westfield
Parking details
None
Additional
Beer, Cocktails, Full Bar, Wheelchair Access

Soups$6.00
House-made Chili, Chicken Tortilla or Wisconsin Beer Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Dip$10.00
Prodigy's Secret Blend, you won't be disappointed, served with house chips
Rock Shrimp Tempura$17.00
Prodigy brings back this Carmel favorite, Succulent Gulf Shrimp served over Frisee, tossed in an Orange Sesame Glaze
Cheesesteak Eggrolls$10.00
2 Eggrolls with Prodigy's Signature Blend, Provolone Cheese & Diced Onion, served with Chipotle Mayonnaise
Sliders$11.00
3 Sliders with your choice of the: Blackened Chicken with Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato or Prodigy's Signature Blend topped with Gruyere, Lettuce & Tomato
Thomas Edison's Stuffed Breadsticks$9.00
Pepperoni & Mozzarella Stuffed Breadsticks served with Marinara & White Queso, Parmesan
Street Tacos
Served in Corn Tortillas, topped with Fresh Peppers, Queso Fresco, Pico de Gallo, finished with Salsa Verde
- each$3.00
- Chicken$10.00
- Braised Beef$10.00
- Steak$12.00
- Shrimp$12.00
Prodigy Nachos$14.00
House-made Chips, topped with Braised Beef, White Queso, Jalapenos, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Guacamole

Wings

12 Wings$16.00
Fried Flavors: Classic Buffalo, Thai Chili, Ginger Teriyaki, Sweet & Smokey BBQ. Smoked Flavors: Louisiana, Sriracha, the Prodigy Smokehouse, Jamaican Jerk. all Wings Served with your Choice of Ranch Or Bleu Cheese
18 Wings$23.00
Fried Flavors: Classic Buffalo, Thai Chili, Ginger Teriyaki, Sweet & Smokey Bbq. Smoked Flavors: Louisiana, Sriracha, the Prodigy Smokehouse, Jamaican Jerk. all Wings Served with your Choice of Ranch Or Bleu Cheese
24 Wings$30.00
Fried Flavors: Classic Buffalo, Thai Chili, Ginger Teriyaki, Sweet & Smokey. Bbq Smoked Flavors: Louisiana, Sriracha, the Prodigy Smokehouse, Jamaican Jerk. all Wings Served with your Choice of Ranch Or Bleu Cheese

Greens

Chicken Caesar Salad$12.00
Fresh greens topped with grilled chicken, croutons, parmesan, and Prodigy's special caesar dressing
Berry Spring Salad$12.00
Mixed Greens, Walnuts, Mixed Berries, Apple Slices, Sun-Dried Tomatoes, tossed in Apple Vinaigrette Dressing
Hot Chicken Salad$14.00
Romaine & Iceberg Lettuce, Nashville Hot Chicken, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Dill Pickle, Celery, Carrots & our House-made Bleu Cheese Dressing
7-iron$9.00
Bigger than your normal wedge. Applewood Smoked Bacon, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Tomato & our House-made Bleu Cheese Dressing
Grilled Shrimp Salad$13.00
Artisan Greens, Shrimp, Avocado, Tomato, Cucumber & Red Onion served with House-made Spicy Dill Ranch
The Innovator$11.00
Stacked Salad with Kale, Apples, Cranberries, Pecans, Grilled Chicken, tossed in our House-made Apple Vinaigrette. Can you name this innovative genius whose favorite food was Kale?

Burgers

The Fire and Ice$11.00
Our Signature Beef Blend Patty is coated with a Sriracha Rub and topped with Creamy Fontina Cheese
The Wanna-Be Goat$9.00
This is our Signature Blend Plain, however you get to "play GM" and select any of our ingredients to help you achieve your goals, $1 per added player
Crabby Patty$14.00
This is our House-made Crab Cake Patty with Cucumber Relish & a side of Ginger Dressing
The Turducken$13.00
Named affectionately for the greatest NFL broadcaster of all time, this Turkey Burger is topped with Asian Slaw, PepperJack Cheese, Avocado & Dijon Mustard served with Duck Fat Pomme Frites & garnished with our Signature Prodigy Chicken Wing
Nacho Mamma$12.00
Prodigy's Signature Blend topped with the accouterments from our Prodigy Nachos
The Crasian$11.00
Prodigy's Signature Blend topped with Peanut Butter, Bacon, Jalapenos & Smoked Gouda
Sheriff$11.00
A few Greats from Tennessee. Prodigy's Signature Blend topped with Swiss, Cheddar & Jack Daniel's Bourbon Glaze
Mozart$12.00
Prodigy's Signature Blend topped with Bleu Cheese, Fried Onion Straws & Zesty Orange Dill Sauce. A Symphony for your taste buds.
The G.O.A.T.$14.00
This Single Prodigy Signature Blended Patty topped with Special Sauce, Lettuce, Cheese, Pickle, Onion on a Sesame Seed Bun & 4 Slices of Applewood Smoked Bacon

Wagyu Burgers

The BBQ Brisket Burger$15.00
Our Signature Wagyu Beef Blend patty is topped with Prodigy's Slow-Roasted BBQ Brisket and Cheddar Cheese
The 16th Masterpiece$15.00
Our Signature Wagyu Blend with 16 Mushrooms, Swiss, & topped with Fontina Cream Cheese
The Captain$15.00
Signature Wagyu Blend topped with American Cheese, Pork Belly & Truffle Mayo
The Prodigy Burger$16.00
Our Signature Wagyu Blend topped with PepperJack, Cheddar, Mushrooms, Caramelized Onion, Red & Green Peppers, & Garlic Aioli

Sandwiches

The Prodigy BBQ Brisket Sandwich$12.00
6 Ounces of our House-Smoked Beef Brisket marinated in Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ Sauce and topped with Crispy Onion Straws
The Prodigy BBQ Sandwich$11.00
Our In-House Slow-Roasted Pulled Pork basted with Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ Sauce. Topped with Cole Slaw and Pickles.
The Hoosier$13.00
An Indiana Tenderloin Breaded and topped with Dijon Mustard.
Stu Unger$12.00
Grilled Chicken, PepperJack Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers, Avocado, Tortilla Strips, & Chipotle Mayo
The Cheesehead$12.00
Sourdough Bread topped with Cheddar, PepperJack, Swiss, Gruyere Cheeses, Tomato, Avocado, & Applewood Smoked Bacon
Farmer's Market$14.00
Cauliflower, Rice, Black & Red Beans, Oats, Faro, Onion, Red Pepper, Basil, Tamari Sauce, topped with Sautéed Onions, Mushrooms, Provolone Cheese, served with Steamed Broccoli. Served on a Gluten-free Bun

Wraps

Steak and Cheese Wrap$12.00
Thinly Sliced Sirloin, House-Made Queso, Red & Green Peppers wrapped in a Jalapeno Cheddar Tortilla
Veggie Wrap$10.00
Roasted Red & Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Grilled Zucchini, Pepperjack Cheese, & Asian Slaw in a Spinach Tortilla
Buffalo Chicken Wrap$11.00
Hand-Battered Crispy Fried Chicken tossed in Buffalo Sauce topped with Bleu Cheese, Shredded Mozzarella, Lettuce, and Tomato. Served in a Jalapeno Cheddar Tortilla
Turkey Florentine Wrap$10.00
Sliced Roasted Turkey, American Cheese, Sautéed Spinach in a Spinach Tortilla. Served with a side of Fresh Fruit

Giant Baked Potatoes

The Prodigy Potato$8.00
A daily special using influence from some of our most popular burgers!
Mexitato$8.00
Shredded Braised Beef, Pepperjack Cheese, Pico Di Gallo, Sour Cream, and Guacamole
Veggietato$8.00
Red & Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Grilled Zucchini, Broccoli, and Swiss Cheese
Chili Max Potato$8.00
Our House-Made Chili topped with Cheddar Cheese, Sour Cream, and Red Onions

The Others

Winner-Winner Chicken Dinner$16.00
Lightly Breaded & Fried Nashville Hot Chicken served with Slaw & Prodigy's Signature 3 Cheese Mac
Fajitas
Served with Green & Red Peppers, Onions & our Fajita Sauce, Guacamole, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream & Cilantro Lime Rice.
- Chicken$14.00
- Steak$16.00
- Shrimp$16.00
The Captain Ahab$16.00
A whale sized portion of Beer Battered Cod served with Coleslaw & Fries
Kung-Pao Chicken$12.00
Marinated, Spicy Stir-fried Chicken & Broccoli, served with Cilantro Lime Rice, topped with Sesame Seeds & Green Onions

Mac Daddy

Prodigy Signature 3-cheese Mac$8.00
Shhh… it's a secret recipe
Shrimp Mac$12.00
Cavatappi Noodles, Shrimp, Signature 3 Cheese Sauce
Short Rib Mac$10.00
Cavatappi Noodles, Braised Beef, Signature 3 Cheese Sauce
Sriracha Mac$8.00
Cavatappi Noodles with Sriracha Seasoning and Prodigy's 3 Cheese Sauce

Sides

Side Salad with Ranch$5.00
Sweet Potato Fries with a Caramel Sauce$4.00
Steamed Broccoli$4.00
Onion Rings$4.00
Truffle Fries$4.00
Fries$3.00
Cole Slaw$3.00
Fresh Fruit$4.00
Duck Fat Pomme Frites$5.00

Kids Menu

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli$6.00
Pepperoni Pizza$6.00
Kids Mac & Cheese$6.00
Mini Cheeseburgers (2)$6.00
Grilled Cheese$6.00
Chicken Tenders$6.00

Milkshakes

Brandy Alexander$11.00
Brandy – Creme de Cacao – Chocolate Ice Cream – Whipped Cream – Nutmeg
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake$11.00
Vanilla Ice Cream – Rumchatta – Fireball
Spiked Root Beer Float$13.00
Vanilla Ice Cream – Jägermeister – Root Beer – Whipped Cream and Cherry
Pineapple Upside Down Cake$11.00
Vanilla Ice Cream – Fresh Pineapple – Spiced Rum – Dark Rum – topped with fresh whipped cream and a cherry
The Dude$11.00
Marshmallow Vodka – Kahlua – Chocolate Ice Cream – Oreos – topped with whipped cream and a cherry
Girl Scout Cookie$11.00
Vanilla Ice Cream – Vodka–Godiva Chocolate Liqueur–Bailey's– Crème de Menthe with whipped cream and a cherry
Deep South$10.00
Jim Beam Bourbon – Vanilla Ice Cream – Chocolate Syrup

Non-Alcoholic Milkshakes:

Chocolate Madness
Chocolate Ice Cream – Oreos – Chocolate Syrup – Whipped Cream and Cherry
- Regular$6.00
- Large$9.00
Cookies and Cream
Vanilla Ice Cream – Oreos – Whipped Cream and Cherry
- Regular$6.00
- Large$9.00
Creamsicle
Vanilla Ice Cream – Orange – Orange Juice – Milk – Orange Garnish
- Regular$6.00
- Large$9.00
Root Beer Float
Vanilla Ice Cream – Root Beer – Whipped Cream
- Regular$8.00
- Large$11.00
Milkshake
Vanilla Ice Cream –Chocolate syrup – Whipped Cream and Cherry
- Regular$5.00
- Large$8.00

What 20 people are saying

Overall ratings and reviews

3.9

3.9 based on all time ratings

3.8Food
3.7Service
3.7Ambience
3.6Value

Noise • Moderate

Sort by

Filters

MM
MeMi
Naples
18 reviews
vip
4.0
18 reviews
Dined on November 1, 2019
overall4food4service4ambience3
There was a musician that night so it was a little loud but it was a fun environment. The food was great.
BW
BelindaW
Indiana
6 reviews
5.0
6 reviews
Dined on October 29, 2019
overall5food5service5ambience5
Great place to eat out! It’s friendly restaurant with food that makes you feel good. My three favorite dishes are the innovator salad, the goat burger and the salmon. My go-to drink is the raspberry mule. So good!
OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
2 reviews
3.0
2 reviews
Dined on October 26, 2019
overall3food5service3ambience2
The service wasn’t amazing - our server just wasn’t extremely attentive but much better than our service the time before this. I enjoy live music at restaurants .. however, it needs to be at a volume which I can still hear the table at my table talking. It was too loud and we were there when these teenagers’ band was playing so it was poor quality music that was way too loud.
d
drwojo
New England
138 reviews
vip
4.0
138 reviews
Dined on October 25, 2019
overall4food3service3ambience3
Good burgers and sandwiches. Service is good but not super fast. We had a large group of people who were drinking bod have thought the service would be more attentive. Nonetheless, Prodigy is a good place to have a fair priced meal.
j
jenp
San Francisco
33 reviews
vip
5.0
33 reviews
Dined on October 23, 2019
overall5food5service5ambience5
Great burgers. The onion rings are the best. Will return.
C
Calibr8tor
Indiana
50 reviews
vip
3.0
50 reviews
Dined on October 20, 2019
overall3food2service2ambience2
Nothing special. Wagyu burger is more expensive and subpar compared to the Burger Study Wagyu burger enjoyed before the Colts game. Dynamite Shrimp breading was mushy but had a nice taste. Stuffed mozzarella bread roll came to table with the majority of cheese having escaped from both ends. This place reminds me of a sports bar compared to a food-first eatery. Prices seemed high for a sports bar however we do not go to sports bars to compare. 7:30 PM on a Sunday with one other table seems odd for a sports bar although the Simpsons blasting onscreen and house speakers may explain the situation.
OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
5 reviews
3.0
5 reviews
Dined on October 13, 2019
overall3food3service4ambience3
Good was so so
JS
JulieS
Indiana
78 reviews
vip
3.0
78 reviews
Dined on October 5, 2019
overall3food4service2ambience4
I've been to Prodigy Bar in the past and enjoyed the food with decent service. This visit had fair service (and I might be generous on that rating). It was odd from beginning to end. First, the very young host looked lost when I checked in. I told him that I had a reservation on Open Table, so he would check us in. He looked at his screen but apparently did not check us in, since I received an email asking if we missed our reservation. Our waiter took our drink orders promptly, but did not deliver our drinks until after we waited a long time and asked him about them (which, by the way, they were sitting on the bar waiting for him). Our food was good, but my friend ordered broccoli on the side and received fries instead. When we told the bar manager who stopped by to ask how things were going, he said he would bring the broccoli right over. It never arrived. My husband ordered a second drink that took quite a while to arrive too. When our bill arrived, we were not charged the special $6 price for the mules (Saturday special), but rather $10 each. When we told the waiter, he brought us $10 in cash and said he didn't want to ask a manager to adjust the bill. The food is good and reasonably priced, but the service was not good at all. We'll think twice about going back. Hoping this was an exception to the rule, but perhaps explained why the restaurant was not very crowded at 6:30 on a Saturday evening.
O
Outstanding
Indiana
14 reviews
5.0
14 reviews
Dined on August 3, 2019
overall5food5service5ambience5
Birthday celebration. Great experience and food.
k
katieo25
Indiana
22 reviews
5.0
22 reviews
Dined on July 20, 2019
overall5food5service5ambience5
Delicious and creative burgers. Our server, Cody, was super! He was friendly, knowledgeable of the menu, attentive, really made the experience a great one. The live music made for a fun evening out.
OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
6 reviews
3.0
6 reviews
Dined on July 14, 2019
overall3food3service4ambience4
My wife and I came in with our two young children last night. We had an enjoyable time, but we weren't blown away. The burgers were decent, but they seemed to be missing something. We both got the "Sheriff" which is a cheeseburger with a Jack Daniels sauce. It was decent, but there was no garnish on the burger, no bacon, etc...it was just kind of boring and needed something more. The fries were really good, and it is a comfortable atmosphere. Maybe I would enjoy a different burger more if I return.
AG
AkaG
Indiana
1 review
5.0
1 review
Dined on July 12, 2019
overall5food5service5ambience5
It was a great night to sit on the patio. Service was excellent. Carson our waiter was very good and worked hard to make our dining experience enjoyable. This will become our new regular.
OT
OpenTable Diner
Indiana
1 review
vip
3.0
1 review
Dined on July 5, 2019
overall3food2service4ambience4
Steak tacos were way overcooked.
SD
StacyD
1 review
5.0
1 review
Dined on June 7, 2019
overall5food1service4ambience2
Yes I would recommend but my food did come out cold, we had a larger party that may have been the issue. They offered to remake but took it off the bill instead. My waitress was attentive, I was only bothered that manager didn’t inquire about the issue. I just feel if I have to pay extra for an item like sweet potato fries they should be hot at least warm when they arrive with my meal. They weren’t too busy for he/she to check with me. I usually don’t write reviews but thought I would share my experience.
MS
MattS
Indiana
5 reviews
vip
4.0
5 reviews
Dined on May 11, 2019
overall4food4service4ambience3
Good burgers, good mix of food. Little pricey, but not too bad. Only complaint was live music was waaaay too loud for size of space, couldn’t hear anyone at my table.
K
Kulerfull
Indiana
78 reviews
vip
5.0
78 reviews
Dined on May 10, 2019
overall5food5service5ambience5
Service was very good and cheerful! The Ted Turner with a friend egg was very good! We also had a burger with blue cheese and onion straws on it. Again very tasty!!
HJ
HJack
Philadelphia
1 review
vip
1.0
1 review
Dined on April 27, 2019
overall1food3service1ambience1
We had a reservation Saturday night at 7:15. We got there to hear the manager say to not sit anyone as the kitchen was behind. They told us that we would get a table as soon as one opened. After 30 mins of waiting we asked about our table as plenty were open and were told it would be another 30 mins. We left without being seated as we had three kids needing to eat. When I reinforced we had a reservation, I was told it’s an automated system and they don’t guarantee a table which has never been the case at any other restaurant using open table. Very disappointed at the lack of transparency when we arrived as we would have left right away.
NF
NikoleF
Indiana
21 reviews
vip
3.0
21 reviews
Dined on April 19, 2019
overall3food3service3ambience5
Very good seasoning on the French fries, we enjoyed the live music and great selection of craft beers
w
wally2016
Indiana
27 reviews
vip
5.0
27 reviews
Dined on April 17, 2019
overall5food4service5ambience5
Bar-b-que pulled pork sandwich was excellent!
CS
CindyS
Indiana
11 reviews
4.0
11 reviews
Dined on April 6, 2019
overall4food4service3ambience4
There were four of us and we ordered a variety of food, from salads to burgers. The restaurant is located in Clay Terrace. The server forgot the bacon, lettuce and tomato on one of the burgers and after she was told, it took a long time to get it, by which time the burger was no longer hot (and was somewhat overdone, but at this point it was too late to send it back). One of the managers brought the forgotten items and he really tried to make up for the mistake. Everything else came out as ordered and was tasty. We liked the industrial décor (although it made it a bit loud) and the menu was varied enough to satisfy most tastes. We'll probably give them another chance.

FAQs

You can order delivery directly from Prodigy Burger & Bar - Carmel using the Order Online button.

Prodigy Burger & Bar - Carmel is rated 3.9 stars by 20 OpenTable diners.

Not available on OpenTable

Unfortunately, this restaurant is not on the OpenTable reservation network.

If you like, we'll notify you by email if this restaurant joins.

Is this your restaurant?

Claim this listing

Order delivery or takeout

Options

Order online

Additional information

Neighborhood
Carmel / Westfield
Cuisines
Burgers, American
Dining style
Casual Dining
Dress code
Casual Dress
Parking details
None
Additional
Beer, Cocktails, Full Bar, Wheelchair Access

Phone number
(317) 569-9996

Prodigy Burger & Bar - Carmel

Not available on OpenTable

Order delivery or takeout

Options

Additional information

The Prelude

Soups$6.00

Buffalo Chicken Dip$10.00

Rock Shrimp Tempura$17.00

Cheesesteak Eggrolls$10.00

Sliders$11.00

Thomas Edison's Stuffed Breadsticks$9.00

Street Tacos

Prodigy Nachos$14.00

Wings

12 Wings$16.00

18 Wings$23.00

24 Wings$30.00

Greens

Chicken Caesar Salad$12.00

Berry Spring Salad$12.00

Hot Chicken Salad$14.00

7-iron$9.00

Grilled Shrimp Salad$13.00

The Innovator$11.00

Burgers

The Fire and Ice$11.00

The Wanna-Be Goat$9.00

Crabby Patty$14.00

The Turducken$13.00

Nacho Mamma$12.00

The Crasian$11.00

Sheriff$11.00

Mozart$12.00

The G.O.A.T.$14.00

Wagyu Burgers

The BBQ Brisket Burger$15.00

The 16th Masterpiece$15.00

The Captain$15.00

The Prodigy Burger$16.00

Sandwiches

The Prodigy BBQ Brisket Sandwich$12.00

The Prodigy BBQ Sandwich$11.00

The Hoosier$13.00

Stu Unger$12.00

The Cheesehead$12.00

Farmer's Market$14.00

Wraps

Steak and Cheese Wrap$12.00

Veggie Wrap$10.00

Buffalo Chicken Wrap$11.00

Turkey Florentine Wrap$10.00

Giant Baked Potatoes

The Prodigy Potato$8.00

Mexitato$8.00

Veggietato$8.00

Chili Max Potato$8.00

The Others

Winner-Winner Chicken Dinner$16.00

Fajitas

The Captain Ahab$16.00

Kung-Pao Chicken$12.00

Mac Daddy

Prodigy Signature 3-cheese Mac$8.00

Shrimp Mac$12.00

Short Rib Mac$10.00

Sriracha Mac$8.00

Sides

Side Salad with Ranch$5.00

Sweet Potato Fries with a Caramel Sauce$4.00

Steamed Broccoli$4.00

Onion Rings$4.00

Truffle Fries$4.00

Fries$3.00

Cole Slaw$3.00

Fresh Fruit$4.00

Duck Fat Pomme Frites$5.00

Kids Menu

Grilled Chicken & Broccoli$6.00

Pepperoni Pizza$6.00