Service was very good. Food portion size was adequate would be better if you were able to choose your own accompaniments. Rest rooms in basement where you have to go down a very narrow long flight of stairs and then walk across the length of the restaurant to reach it.
The restaurant is magical and the food is out of this world amazing. From the moment we walked in, to the moment we left - the experience was 5 stars.
The food was better than we could’ve imagined - it was truly one of the most magnificent ding experiences we have had. It will be hard to beat the quality of the food
Great Italian restaurant in lower Manhattan, beautiful room , great service and fantastic food !! Get the raviolo!
Continuing to provide an outstanding dining experience from start to finish.
Visited for a social birthday and was not disappointed. Food was outstanding.
Superb food and service. I’ve dined here many times and plan to return many more.
We enjoyed it as allways.
Excellent food and perfect service.
It's always a pleasure going to Scalini Fedeli knowing that it's never going to disappoint. The food was terrific, excellent service, and wonderful evening!! There's no better place to dine!! The fish was superb!!
Everything was fine, the only “complaint” I have is that it was a little too quiet. Less than half the tables were filled on a Sunday so it was a little too quiet. Suggest bumping the lovely music up a notch to compensate for that. Overall, a great romantic experience.
Everything was outstanding. Will definitely be returning in the future.
We had a wonderful time celebrating our valentines dinner at this romantic place, food and service were tremendous !! We look forward to seeing regular menu as well
Great service, Delicious food and Good wine list!!
Outstanding in Every Way!
We went to Scalini to celebrate Valentine's day and we were treated like royalty. We have been to the restaurant before and loved the food, but their Valentine's' menu was exceptional. The service is the best you can find in New York City and the food a step above of most two star Michelin restaurants. We will definitely be back.
Another wonderful evening at Scalini. The food is amazing, the service is classy and polished and the ambiance is stunning.This is one of New York's finest restaurants and a great place to celebrate a special occasion.
Food is delicious. Service was A+++. Great date spot
Valentine’s Day was a great experience. I just wish they were a little faster with the bring out the next dish. It was a fixed memu and it took them a long time to get the next dish to my date and I.
Average food. Overbooked.
The food wasn’t amazing, of course we are Vegan so limited choices but the staff was amazing!
Very good restaurant, we went there for Valentine’s Day and were pleasantly surprised of the quality of the food.
We’d definitely go back on our next trip to NYC
Our primary go to special night out restaurant
Great spot for business meeting
This place is one of those rare gems where everything was amazing. I can't describe how much I enjoyed the food, service and ambiance.
Go eat here.
It was more than a meal, it was a dining experience. Perfect for a special occasion. The menu was limited but had enough choices in each category not to be stuck. The portion was small and the prices were high.
The in between meal tastings were a nice unexpected addition. But really not recognizable either by looks or taste. The waiter should have identified what they were. The main courses were lacking in sides, the same feeling of unrecognizable vegetables concoctions as the mid meal tastings. I had the four delicious scallops, which would have been fine if it was accompanied by a recognizable amount of vegetables. The wait staff was as wonderful as the perfect vodka gimlet that I enjoyed thoroughly. The sliver of dessert was tasty and adequate. I would go back with friends for a memorable evening in New York.
Great restaurant, ambience, service, and food. We received several delicious complimentary additions to our meal
From start to finish everything was perfect. Amazing food with a fantastic wine list to match. WILL return when next in NY
Had a tremendous meal at this restaurant in Tribeca, was extremely cold night so the restaurant Was not 100% full , we loved everything we had in our prix fixe , staff was also professional and friendly
Food was spectacular. Service was excellent. Wines were amazing but not ridiculously expensive. Its an expensive place but well worth it. Handled my gluten free requirements fairly easily.
This elegant restaurant offers prefixe choices. We chose the four course dinner which was actually 7 courses with all the food they added to our order , The food is really of the highest cuisine which rivals any restaurant I’ve been to Italy. The service was impeccable.This is by far one of the best Italian restaurant in New York!
Not up to par fir the price
I’ve been going to Scalini Fedeli with my wife since our first date through our wedding and every anniversary since. They treat you like royalty.
The food is amazing and even though it’s a 3 course price fix menu, they give you at least 5 other small bites. You never leave feeling hungry.
Duo of Beef contains one of the best dry-aged strip steaks I've had. Consistently excellent all around. One of the finest restaurants in the world. Nothing more to say.
Wonderful service, food and ambiance. Would definitely return.
Half of the restaurant was closed. But food is delicious as always.
Wonderful New Year’s Eve dinner , Beautiful room incredible food and service all contributing to a great experience!!!
Super attentive service and AWESOME food made for a super special birthday celebration! Highly recommend for a truly exceptional experience!
I loved this restaurant, the food was fantastic and service great , one of Manhattans best !! Look forward to coming back
Scalini Fedeli is rated 4.8 stars by 2576 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.