Magret of Duck Au Poivre
Choucroute, caramalized apples, maple cider jus
Grilled Prime-Beef Burger on Homemade Ciabatta Roll
Choice of cheese, herbed steak fries
Seasonal Oysters on the Half Shell*
Grapefruit mignonette (minimum of 3)
It was great to eat outdoors, great weather, but we experienced a lot of road noise, trucks braking, motorcycles revving up, etc. Not exactly relaxing dinner music!
Short ribs were perfect. Service was very good The chef’s tasting sample was awesome. Need to be on the menu
Another wonderful dining experience.
It was a nice evening but their credit card machine broke and we still have an outstanding bill without any understanding of the final amount
EAST COAST HALIBUT
cannellini beans, chanterelle mushrooms, cherry tomatoes, red pepper broth
And it was as good as you can get. The food is as always fabulous. I can't wait to go again.
Our experience was amazing! The food was to die for and the service was wonderful!
Were seated in tavern - same menu. Oysters were cold and fresh. Shirmp/avocado salad was terrific. Prime rib came as ordered - med rare and very tender. Halibut was properly done and well presented with cannelini beans/tomatoes. Will go again soon.
Unique meals which are outstanding. Enjoyed the creamy cold corn soup.
Short Ribs were marvelous, as was the Halibut.
Malbec was a perfect paring to the short ribs, and my significant other thought the Chardonnay paired quite well the Haibut.
The Terrace was comfortable; service was marvelous.
I’d compare the quality of Sydney to that of Lancaster’s Belvedere!
oysters and the angus steak were very good, highly recommend.
Our server was delightful; very efficient time wise. Food was very good & she made great suggestions
Nice outdoor seating and good food! A little pricey.
Lovely patio area. Street noise was loud at times.
Food was excellent.
OMG!!! Best kept secret. Sooooo fortunate to have a restaurant like Sidney!!
Delicious food--very high end (especially for Central PA). Our server was fantastic--knowledgeable and engaging. Host and table side service was on point. A tiny bit noisy when the dining room filled out, but otherwise a great experience.
Sidney has the best oysters we have ever eaten. The food is always excellent and the service is so good. We have been going there for years and love it!
We love everything about this restaurant!
Delicious dinner. Lovely service.
We’ve been going there for years and it is still our favorite place in the area. The food, the service, the atmosphere-everything was amazing. I try to tell everyone in the Harrisburg area about it.
Food portions are just the right size. Everything was delicious! Worth the money. Service was excellent.
Excellent service in a relaxing historic atmosphere. Food was beyond our expectations.
Love this place!
Favorite Central PA restaurant. Only negative was despite not being extremely crowded, it was hard to hear our waitress.
Everything was great. Food was delicious. Good portion sizes. Great drinks. Great service. Would definitely return when we are in the area again.
The overall feel and comfort of the restaurant was refreshing and delightful. The service and the interaction with the waitress was pleasant. She was very embracing and nice. Extremely helpful and was consistently checking on how we were and if we needed anything. The food was fantastic with flavor and amount. I had a steak sirloin and my wife had free range chicken. Extremely flavorful and juicy. Both my wife and I had one alcoholic drink, an appetizer, two main course meals and two desserts. Without tip our bill was $150. With tip it was $191 so make sure you bring your wallet. We tipped well above the 20% mark as our waitress was great. I would recommend Sidney Tavern to people but I wouldn't recommend going often as it would break the bank.
Great little restaurant,service is great,the food is incredible.This restaurant is a little bit of heaven in East Berlin Pa.
Good and service was outstanding! We will be back.
Main dining room is pleasant. Optional seating in tavern section and patio (weather permitting). Nice selection of first course and entrees. Desserts excellent as well. In all a pleasant dining experience.
We go here several times each season. The menu is always changing we find that to be wonderful. Never dull dining like many other places in the area. This is a old colonial home restored to beauty with a top notch Chef thats right, not a cook, but a top culinary school Chef. Everything from the drinks to dessert were amazing. Even our youngest girl tossed back the oysters on the half shell looking fir more, haha. We can’t wait for another occasion to come back. The service is spot on. What a wonderful birthday for my step father.
The food was fabulous. Great variety of first courses. The calamari was wonderful. Service was on point. Its a restaurant you cant miss.
Experience was awesome after we moved from the bar area to main dining room.
This was our second visit and was as good as the first. 5 star restaurant!
The food was amazing! Loved it. Highly recommend it. Have been there 3 times now and the food and service have been perfect!
Food was excellent a great place to dine. Service was great.
Our request for special seating needs were immediately and considerately provided. The meal, as always, was excellently presented. The special flavors in the curry char dish and the free range chicken were awesome. The wait staff provided excellent care and attention.
Everything was up to usual Sidney standards. Great service, great food, great ambience.
First experience at this restaurant. Awesome appetizers. Prime rib was cooked properly at medium rare but “chewy”. Desert was great. Will look forward to going back to try another main course. Waitress attentive and helpful. Should have gone with her seafood suggestion.
Fantastic food and great atmosphere. They tried to keep couples and small groups away from the louder parties.
Sydney Tavern is a gift! You simply can't find food like this elsewhere in the Gettysburg area. My husband and I dined at Sydney for our anniversary, so it was a bit of a splurge. Superb food, tremendous wine selection, extremely attentive service, and lovely historic setting. My favorites were the pate and the creme brulee.
Sidney is rated 4.8 stars by 1152 OpenTable diners.