Had the edamame appetizer. Very large portion and good. Filet was cooked to perfection and loaded baked potato was yummy but cold. Happy hour there has great drink and appetizer selections as well. Service was amazing. As a side note Ava’s next door has the same owner and also worth a stop for their meatballs!

I selected Theo's because their menu offers a good variety of dishes (my dining companion cannot eat seafood). We enjoyed a delicious roasted turkey dinner with all the trimmings at an amazing price of only $10. Our server was very personable and attentive to our needs. Will definitely return!

Awesome! We’ll look frward to going back!

Our server was better than outstanding!!! We will be back!

The food was excellent, waiter chance provided a great experience. Great place for quiet romantic dinner.

Great food and service!

food was excellent
Our waiter Chance put us upstairs by ourselves
He was a terrific waiter

Awesome oysters and Delmonico Steak. My wife had the Filet. Delicious

We were from out of town on Valentine’s Day dinner. We could only get 8:30, on open table, but I called back on Sunday and was able to get a reservation for 7:30. Very accommodating

Valentines dinner, filet melts in the mouth, consistently great waitstaff, very attentive but by no means intrusive

Valentine’s Day dinner. Our server was amazing. Our reservation were when the restaurant just opened. We were greeted warmly and promptly. The door was outstanding. Will definitely return and recommend to my friends.

From food, to waitstaff, to manager, to atmosphere - Nothing beats Theo’s!

Among the better steakhouses we have enjoyed. A lovely dinner, great service, and a really cozy atmosphere. We’ll be back.

Everything was awesome.

Awesome experience as always. Service was great well as food. Highly recommend for a relaxing Date night!

Delicious food, friendly service, great COVID precautions

4 people and Several dishes were not very hot. Filet tough. Oysters were very good and salmon dish good. French onion soup not hot. Mashed potatoes cold w the filet. Shared a dish w husband - sliced tenderloin w veggies. $80+ and just very average. Bread basket great. New to area & first time there and pretty disappointed compared to what others told us.

We had a great table upstairs and socially distanced. We really enjoyed the experience!

Theo’s NEVER disappoints! Food was delicious!

The food is always outstanding as well as the service.

Have walked by Theo's a hundred times. It is non-assuming and never got my attention. However, looking for a nice place for a birthday dinner and Theo's popped up in the search. Took a chance...
And it paid off. The service was excellent. Ally was attentive and very helpful. Water glass never dry and if anything was amiss, she was on it.
The food was terrific. I had the NY Strip and a baked potato. My wife had the Shrimp and Grits. We ordered a side of roasted Brussel Sprouts. All of it was prepared the way we wanted and exceptionally flavorful!!
The atmosphere was very comfortable. We were not overdressed and probably could have worn jeans and still felt comfortable. We sat near the fireplace which completed the ambiance on a cold January evening.
We have already planned our next visit.

As always, food was excellent, server was great and the atmosphere is wonderful!

The service and food at Theos are always the best! French onion soup to die for. And the steaks are always delicious!

Perfect food. Great wait staff. Great experience all the way around

Amazing experience! All of their staff was extremely friendly and knowledgeable on suggestions! We had an amazing dinner and will definitely be back! Try their cocktails you won’t regret it! Steak was cooked perfectly and the shrimp appetizers was so good! Highly recommend trying Theo’s if you are in St. Michael’s!!

My husband and I love this gem of a restaurant. From the food to the service to the atmosphere, everything was fantastic. The food was amazing. Their brussel sprouts were out of this world delicious and the jam burger was exceptional. Our waitress was attentive and sweet. The cocktails were superb- I had a rosemary margarita and peartini. We will definitely be back again on our next visit to St. Michael's!

The service, food, drinks were all excellent.

One of the best meals we have ever had! From the bread basket to the dessert, everything was absolute perfection! And if the food was not enough, the staff were nothing short of amazing, making us feel like VIPs the entire evening.

Definitely great for a date night :) They have a great selection and the happy hour cocktail prices couldnt be better.

Excellent dining experience. Great menu and food. Oysters, shrimp, steak, chocolate mousse, wine & spirits.

We had a great experience at Theos. The steaks and burgers are the best. Salads are great. I have celiac disease and had many gluten free options.
Our waiter was so friendly and helpful. We will be back

Another excellent evening at Theo’s. Thank you. Your food is outstanding and the service superb, from everyone.

FYI, we like your onion rings better than the onion straws.

1st time at Theo's we were celebrating our 17th wedding anniversary. The service and food were outstanding. They truly helped to make our anniversary memorable.

We ordered four steaks and three were not cooked to preference. One filet was over cooked and had little taste, and the other two (strip and rib-eye, which was $85) were both very under-cooked even after being sent back. Our waiter seemed very busy and we relied on another server for getting items. The steaks come with mashed potatoes but if you want to substitute for a baked potato you will add $4 on top of the entree price...I feel that is a little much. For a steakhouse, we were very disappointed and will not go back on our next visit to St. Mikes.

Great dinner to usher in the new year. The filet was excellent and service was outstanding.

Always great food! Friendly peeps!

Great except don't see need for a tv in this type setting.

A wonderful dinner on Christmas Eve!

Theo's St Michaels is one of our favorite restaurants! Always good, always fresh, and the service is fantastic.

Terrific Sunday supper add in great service, nice evening all around