Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Spicy Tomato Marmalade, Scallion, Hass Avocado
Grilled Marinated Chicken Thigh, Pico de Gallo, Avocado Salsa, Queso Fresco
Best Margaritas I have had in a long time. Service was great. Food was good. Would return for drinks any time!
Food came out wrong then when correct food came out it meat was dry onions burnt. Very surprised used to always have a good meal. Off night for Tocola
Food was great, definitely recommend the tacos. And churro sundae!
It was great
Food and drinks were excellent as always and the service was attentive and polite!
Outdoor dining tables are not reservable, but we lucked out and got seated outside. Covid protocols made me feel safe. Service was great and I enjoyed my dinner and sangria. Would definitely go here again.
We love Tocolo Cantina and always enjoy the food. Our latest visit on Mother’s Day was just as wonderful as always and the service was EXCELLENT. Our server was very attentive and kind. I would always recommend this place to anyone.
I have been to this place million times but today this new manager lady was above n beyond super sweet. There was this rude guy before that i didnt see but lso happy
To see a friendly face .
Great food and Great service!
Went to celebrate a birthday no one acknowledged this even thought it was included in the reservation and in person. Regardless I gave them 5 stars because I’ve been here many times before and it’s always been a good experience. The food and atmosphere were great and it was just a pleasure to be out. Disappointed though re: acknowledgment of the celebration.
Service was just horrible today. Very surprised
Very comfortable. Fun atmosphere/music. Food and drinks were delicious!
Really delicious food! Good prices and good portions size!
The restaurant was closed. I'm not sure how my reservation was confirmed by but it was closed
Great night catching up with a friend, dinner and drinks were so good. This place did a great job following the guidelines. The churros sundae was excellent!!! It felt safe and will def come back again.
Service was amazing. Very covid safe. Drinks were amazing but food was mediocre.
Cinco de Mayo was a packed scene - the entire staff was on their game. Accommodating the tent, the bar, the walk-in’s & the restaurant.
Always “our go to restaurant”! Great food, drinks, ambiance.
See you soon!
Juan and Illeane
The female manager sat us near the bar at first when there were plenty of unoccupied tables throughout the restaurant. I assumed this was an oversight or a simple lapse in judgment. On the way out though, my boyfriend forgot to wear his mask while exiting. When the female manager reminded him of the policy he apologized immediately but she admonished him anyway adding "There are signs everywhere". Her tone was rude and considering that she was blocking the exit and barely moved when I said "excuse me" I can only assume her customer service skills generally leave something to be desired. Everyone else was polite, but there are too many Mexican restaurants in the area to deal with that.
Great place for a first date! Hostess and server sweet and accommodating Recommend the Birria tacos. Will definitely be back.
Casamigos Margarita with Strawberry was amazing. Going back for that again. Pulled Pork Taco’s were Good to go!!!!!!
The food & service were amazing. Definitely do the guac & empanadas for apps! The drinks were also amazing, especially their valentines specials!
Food was amazing!!! Will definitely be coming back!
I love this place! Delicious food and great service!
My husband and I enjoyed the food so much, we've made reservations for this weekend again.
Always a delicious meal and great service
Tocolo is such a great place. Always a great time. The food and the drinks are simply delicious. One of my favorite places to visit. Totally recommend.
Fine, fine, had a great time!
Quality "Modern Mexican" (some would call it Tex-Mex) in the usually busy The Gallery At Westbury Plaza shopping center. Great lunch spot, particularly when you are already shopping in this complex. The ambience is nice, and it isn’t too noisy. At the moment, there are fewer table inside and there are partitions between the table. These are welcome precautions taken during this COVID era we are in at right now.
Our server was efficient and attentive – not too intrusive but present whenever we needed anything. As for the food, my party of the enjoyed everything we ordered - Yucateco guacamole with chips, steak fajitas, chicken tacos, & grilled fish tacos. The food was more than enough, and we left full but without ever feeling gross afterwards. The staff took necessary safety/sanitation measures like wearing gloves and masks and thoroughly wiping down tables with sanitary wipes as soon as diners left.
Additional outdoor dining is clutch and in high demand on nicer days like this past Saturday. The pricing is fair if not really good for the quality and quantity of food you get. Parking is available in the spacious lot, although be forewarned that it can be pretty busy during prime shopping hours. All in all, an enjoyable experience and we definitely will come back. Hoping to check out the dinner scene soon.
I think my expectations were high and I was disappointed. I've definitely had tastier and better seasoned food. The food was average.
Julio our server was wonderful and helpful he answered our questions. The pricing was fair and the food was delicious!
Pleasantly surprised not the most authentic Mexican food you’ll get but very close, and very tasty.
We all thought that we were being rushed . I understand that it was Friday but like it's covid and not all the people get the time off from work so the waiter should have let us sit instead of rushing us
Simon was the best server ever. Loved that guy.
Not only is the food delicious, but the service and atmosphere is great as well! They are also extremely covid compliant! Highly recommend!!
I was pleasantly surprised how great the food was. The restaurant is much smaller in person that I expected. However the service was great and the mixed fajitas delicious! I just wish they had more outdoor seating as I am not going to be eating indoors!! But I would certainly go back!!
Wonderful welcome and terrific service. Very good drinks. Menu was somewhat limited but food Muy bien.
Nothing too special. Nothing memorable.
They accommodated us within 5minutes! I love this place !!!
First time we were eating at a restaurant, all steps were followed for safety.
Food was delicious as always!
Would recommend to anyone who enjoys Mexican food!
You can order delivery directly from Tocolo Cantina using the Order Online button. Tocolo Cantina also offers delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Tocolo Cantina also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 222-0060.
Tocolo Cantina is rated 4.5 stars by 419 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.