9 Best Home Cooking Restaurants In Fishers Island

9 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Molto Bene

4.7

Exceptional(559)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Merrick

Booked 2 times today

Great neighborhood restaurant. Good consistently delicious and a very attentive staff

2. Joanne Trattoria

4.3

Awesome(3304)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Lincoln Square

We visited Joanne Trattoria for lunch and it was the cosiest perfect lunch spot. Staff were extremely friendly and food was delicious. Will be visiting again. 🤍

3. Mima Vinoteca

4.7

Exceptional(380)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Irvington

Booked 6 times today

Mima is a little gem in the heart of a little town. We are so lucky to have the quality of food and ambience that Mima brings to Irvington.

4. Paola's Cafe

4.8

Exceptional(27)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Upper East Side

Booked 12 times today

Great local place with excellent food. Pricing was moderate which made for tremendous value.

5. Panini Grill

4.8

Exceptional(183)

$$$$

• Home cooking • West Brighton

Booked 2 times today

My dining experience at Panini Grill was truly exceptional. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere felt welcoming, vibrant, and full of positive energy. The staff was attentive, kind, and genuinely committed to making sure every detail was perfect. The food was outstanding — fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. Every dish had a richness and balance that showed real care in the kitchen. The service was equally impressive, with the team checking in just enough to make sure I had everything I needed without ever feeling rushed. Panini Grill is the kind of place you look forward to returning to. A wonderful experience from start to finish.

6. Via Trenta

4.6

Exceptional(215)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Astoria

Booked 1 time today

Food and service were great. Brought out of town family there for authentic Italian. Everyone had a blast.

7. Pizzaiolo

4.5

Awesome(55)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Ridgewood, New Jersey

Booked 1 time today

The food was wonderful and the service exemplary! It was a wonderful dinner. Can’t wait to dine there again!

8. The Nest

5.0

Exceptional(0)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Williamsburg

Inspired by the comfort of a countryside gathering place, The Nest serves farm-fresh rotisserie chicken, delicious egg dishes, homemade pastries, vibrant seasonal meals, craft cocktails, and thoughtfully selected wines in the heart of Williamsburg. Whether you're joining us for a relaxed weeknight dinner, weekend brunch, or drinks with friends, The Nest is a place to slow down, connect, and enjoy honest food made with care.

9. Cherry's Lounge

4.1

Excellent(19)

$$$$

• Home cooking • Jersey City

I had the breakfast platter with home fries & a lychee martini 10/10 I will be back

Best Home Cooking Restaurants in Fishers Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

9 restaurants available nearby

1. Molto Bene

2. Joanne Trattoria

3. Mima Vinoteca

4. Paola's Cafe

5. Panini Grill

6. Via Trenta

7. Pizzaiolo

8. The Nest

9. Cherry's Lounge

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable