30 Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

30 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

Icon

1. Gage & Tollner

4.8

Exceptional(456)

$$$$

• American • Downtown Brooklyn

Booked 75 times today

shovanne got us the best table in the house and james made our meal so special!! and shoutout to Emma for getting us a table at Sunken Harbor :) amazing staff and great food with the best ambience

Icon

2. Sailor

4.7

Exceptional(361)

$$$$

• Bistro • Fort Greene

Booked 74 times today

Superb, really one of the best places in NY. Elegant, thoughtful, beautiful ingredients, simple but surprising dishes, and a informal and playful but professional service

3. Botte Brooklyn

4.4

Awesome(194)

$$$$

• Italian • Downtown Brooklyn

Booked 15 times today

Everything was amazing. They were busy yet we felt right at home, like family. Rigatoni was off the chart, burrata and rice balls were insane and dessert was heaven.

4. Verde on Smith

4.5

Awesome(684)

$$$$

• Italian • Cobble Hill

The meal and service was great. Will definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends and family. Can’t wait to go again

5. Fragole

4.9

Exceptional(151)

$$$$

• Italian • Carroll Gardens

Booked 2 times today

We decided to try a new place and we are very glad we did. Excellent food, service, and ambiance. The price was excellent as well. We certainly will be back.

Icon

6. Chambers

4.9

Exceptional(940)

$$$$

• American • TriBeCa

Booked 27 times today

Excellent food, wine and service. A meal to remember!

7. Westville Dumbo

4.5

Awesome(578)

$$$$

• American • DUMBO

Booked 16 times today

Great staff and food. Everyone was attentive and kind. We had someone in our party that had celiac and they did an incredible job letting us know what was safe for her to eat. This one's a keeper.

8. Pizza Secret

4.3

Awesome(135)

$$$$

• Contemporary Italian • Park Slope

Booked 2 times today

I want to start by saying I did not read any reviews before I picked the place, so I had no idea what to expect. The restaurant was small and tables were very close, making it extremely loud, plus it was very busy and hot. It was already packed when we got there for our 6:00 reservation and people just kept coming in behind us for their reservations as well. My husband and I got the focaccia and the buffala pizza to share. The food was quick and excellent! The servers were very busy, so it was difficult to get refills on our drinks and after the food came out, we didn’t see anyone again until I flagged them down for the check. Overall, the food was excellent and I would definitely go again, probably not on a Friday night though. There are many things on the menu I’d like to try and everything I saw when looking around looked great.

9. Piccoli Trattoria

4.9

Exceptional(370)

$$$$

• Italian • Park Slope

Booked 12 times today

Great Friday night dinner. We were party of four, each with an entree and dessert. There was not a speck left on any plate. Food was delicious and staff was friendly. I’ll be back.

A photo of Metropolis by Marcus Samuelsson restaurant

10. Metropolis by Marcus Samuelsson

4.3

Awesome(869)

$$$$

• Steakhouse • Financial District

Booked 11 times today

The restaurant was beautiful, definitely an Instagramable moment! The food was incredible along with presentation. Would definitely go back! We had the cornbread, tomato salad, pretzel & lox, oysters, fried olives, Brussel sprouts, fries and snapper.

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Areas

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

30 restaurants available nearby

1. Gage & Tollner

2. Sailor

3. Botte Brooklyn

4. Verde on Smith

5. Fragole

6. Chambers

7. Westville Dumbo

8. Pizza Secret

9. Piccoli Trattoria

10. Metropolis by Marcus Samuelsson

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable