Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Restaurants near Bay Street Theatre

Price
Cuisine
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility

366 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Sag Harbor Tavern restaurant
1. Sag Harbor Tavern
4.3
Awesome(110)
$$$$
• Gastro Pub • Sag Harbor
For many years I wanted to pay homage to my Grandmother Else who immigrated in the 1930s to my beloved neighborhood, Red Hook in Brooklyn, NY.I built my dream concept by tapping into my love of old NYC Taverns and imagined where my Grandmother would have wanted to go with family and friends and the Red Hook Tavern was born.Offering a timeless menu now known for its handmade pastas, spicy mussels and the legendary 45-Day Dry Aged Cheeseburger, alongside its coveted wine list, that guests come from all over the world to enjoy.Sag Harbor Tavern is a continuation of a tribute to my Grandmothers in beautiful Sag Harbor, NY. My Grandmother, Veronica was a Navy Nurse in WWII and a proud member of the American Legion. A building that we are humbled to now share with other proud Veterans.Sag Harbor is a special village with a great history and a wonderful community of wildly talented, hardworking folks. We are honored to be a part of this community and hope to do it proud.~Billy
A photo of Dopo la Spiaggia - Sag Harbor restaurant
2. Dopo la Spiaggia - Sag Harbor
4.6
Exceptional(354)
$$$$
• Italian • Sag Harbor
Booked 19 times today
Dopo La Spiaggia is the Italian restaurant located across the street from the waterfront in Sag Harbor. We pride ourselves with serving the Hamptons' finest Tuscan cuisine including steaks, pastas, seafood & more. Enjoy the bar with the best crafted cocktails ovelooking beautiful sag harbor marina. "Dopo Sag" is local's favorite for a reason. Come and enjoy unique experience at our intimate dining room with fireplace or outdoor patios. Lunch or dinner, we are here for for you!
A photo of Beacon Sag Harbor restaurant
3. Beacon Sag Harbor
4.8
Exceptional(96)
$$$$
• American • Sag Harbor
Booked 27 times today
Perched above the Sag Harbor Cove Yacht Club, The Beacon offers one of the East End's most stunning waterfront views — sweeping across Sag Harbor Bay all the way to Shelter Island. It's the quintessential Hamptons sunset, best enjoyed from our expansive upstairs porch with a cocktail in hand. A seasonal restaurant open through the warmer months, we've been serving dinner on the harbor since 1999.The menu draws on American, Mediterranean, and Asian influences, with signature dishes like steamed mussels, pork belly buns, and baked halibut, plus homemade desserts worth saving room for.Owners David Loewenberg and Sam McCleland met on the Hamptons restaurant scene in the 1990s and have been partners ever since. In 2012, they opened The Bell & Anchor, extending The Beacon's hospitality into the off-season.Casually upscale and warmly inviting — the perfect spot for a summer evening on the water.
A photo of K Pasa restaurant
4. K Pasa
4.6
Exceptional(163)
$$$$
• Tapas / Small Plates • Sag Harbor
Booked 3 times today
We love great tacos. Not the traditional fried shells, but inventive, healthy and delicious tacos that you will want to eat every day. K Pasa means neighborhood, local, in both our food and style. We are right around the corner and we know where you like to sit and what you like to eat. Tacos and tequila taste even better with a Sag Harbor water view.K Pasa is an American taqueria created by chefs and restaurateurs who live and work here. Inspired by the all-day après beach lifestyle of the East End, Laguna Beach, and Malibu. Our tacos (tequila bar and rosés) are for sharing. We’re gluten-free & vegan-friendly and frequented by sailors, pirates, and fun-seekers. K Pasa is about keeping the local summer vibe going all year round.
A photo of The Bell & Anchor restaurant
5. The Bell & Anchor
4.8
Exceptional(709)
$$$$
• Seafood • Sag Harbor
Booked 25 times today
In 2012, The Bell & Anchor opened for its first summer. Now, open for much more and much longer than just summer: the waterside Sag Harbor restaurant conceived and operated by David Loewenberg & Sam McCleland stands firmly along side its sister restaurant, the Beacon. At The Bell & Anchor, you'll experience food and wine with deep flavors and textures. The restaurant pulls its inspiration from the rich & deep history Sag Harbor, Noyac, Peconic & the region offer: local seafood, steak, beer, vegetables, and wine. Enjoy!We offer reservations online for our dining room, bar, and patio. Reservations can be made up to two weeks in advance.
A photo of Vine Street Cafe restaurant
6. Vine Street Cafe
4.7
Exceptional(2069)
$$$$
• American • Shelter Island
Booked 22 times today
Chef/Owners Lisa & Terry Harwood opened Vine Street Cafe in 2003. Located on South Ferry Road, just 1.5 miles from the South Ferry. Chef Terry works with area farmers, fishermen & vineyards and features their natural bounty on his seasonal menus. We make everything in house and Lisa's desserts, ice creams and fruit crisps are no exception. Recently, we opened a small market behind the restaurant. This is where you pick up take-out orders while stocking your home pantry. Specialty catering is available along with ready fresh meals such as meatballs, chicken salad, bread, smoked ribs, BBQ Sauce and a selection of artisan pastas. Reservations are highly recommended year round.
A photo of Almond - Bridgehampton restaurant
7. Almond - Bridgehampton
4.7
Exceptional(1835)
$$$$
• American • Bridgehampton
Booked 8 times today
NOTE: Please call the restaurant at 631.537.5665 if you having trouble making a reservation here.Seasonal, Local & Artisanal Since 2001 Co-founder and chef Jason Weiner creates seasonally focused ever-changing menus that are guided by a market driven ethos. We highlight our personal relationships with growers, fishermen, artisans and winemakers.Our menus are artisanal and market driven featuring some updated takes on classic french/mediterannean cuisine, ethnic street food and lots of stuff in between. We are obsessive about the handmade...We hang our own charcuterie, grind our own sausage, ferment our own kimchi, dry age own steaks, and smoke our own fish & bacon.The wine list, handpicked by co-owner Eric Lemonides, offers an affordable selection of wines. Specialty cocktails, NY craft beers, and raw bar selections, along with the entire menu are available at the restaurant’s 15 seat bar.
A photo of Dopo il Ponte restaurant
8. Dopo il Ponte
4.6
Exceptional(313)
$$$$
• Italian • Bridgehampton
Booked 9 times today
Dopo il Ponte is a modern Italian restaurant in the heart of the Bridgehampton. Offering traditional best hand-made pastas, prime meats, local vegetables and seafood and much more! Lunch or dinner, try our thin crust pizza made in wood fired oven. Our bar offers great selection of wines and crafted cocktails. Romantic dinner for 2 or large event, we welcome you to enjoy a great meal, cocktails or your next Special Occasion with us. Our otdoor seating is amongs the best in hamptons.
A photo of Elaia Estiatorio restaurant
9. Elaia Estiatorio
4.7
Exceptional(453)
$$$$
• Greek • Bridgehampton
Booked 12 times today
ELAIA | (el-ah'-yah) | ἐλαία, ας, ἡ | Olive TreeYiassou, and Welcome Home. This Is Elaia, the Olive Tree, the foundation from which we create. Here we invite you to dine with us and relax into the Greek way of living. Our food is uncomplicated, healthy, and pairs beautifully with our selection of Greek wines. Please come and experience the fruits of the Olive Tree as we do – with Love, Hospitality, and Gratitude for all it provides.
A photo of M.J. Dowling's restaurant
10. M.J. Dowling's
4.5
Awesome(314)
$$$$
• American • Sag Harbor
Welcome to MJ Dowling’s Steakhouse and Tavern, a friendly neighborhood pub. Family owned and operated, MJ Dowling’s offers a casual dining experience with great food at reasonable prices. Featuring an eclectic menu, MJ’s is sure to please every member of your family. From juicy burgers and steaks to fajitas and nachos, we aim to please. Our nightly specials offer some of our most popular dishes at an even lower prices. Whether you are getting together with friends, going to happy hour or treating the family to a dinner out, MJ’s is the place to be! Be sure to check our game room which features two pool tables, a basketball hoop, and several arcade games!

How is content generated

Dining near Bay Street Theatre at a glance

Updated on

Most popular restaurant

popular restaurant

The Bell & Anchor

4.8

View restaurant

Discover local gems

Exceptional reviews

Most popular cuisine

popular cuisine

Italian

Average bill amount

$41 to $70

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • monicaGold
    New York City •2 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 3 days ago
    Everything was perfect! Food was absolutely delicious and service phenomenal!
    More info
    Beacon Sag Harbor$$$$• American• Sag Harbor
    •
    4.8
  • John
    New York City •23 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 5 days ago
    The Bell & Anchor is a great place to have dinner! Friendly staff and a terrific menu.
    More info
    The Bell & Anchor$$$$• Seafood• Sag Harbor
    •
    4.8
  • Larry
    New York City •10 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on 21 Sept 2026
    This is such a cozy and welcoming spot! Delicious food and a beautiful view for the early birds. Loved it!
    More info
    Dopo la Spiaggia - Sag Harbor$$$$• Italian• Sag Harbor
    •
    4.6
  • CamilleGold
    New York City •52 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on 12 Sept 2026
    My partner and I were craving hamburgers on a beautiful summer evening, so we looked forward to sitting in the lovely garden at Sag Harboe Tavern. The burgers were fabulous — thick and very tasty — with their own secret mixture; I tried to get the recipe — lol. The cottage fries weren't crispy enough. They had an odd texture and flavor. They could definitely be improved upon. The service was excellent, and the ambiance is always so vibrant, yet serene. Always love dining at Sag Harbor Tavern. Thank you!
    More info
    Sag Harbor Tavern$$$$• Gastro Pub• Sag Harbor
    •
    4.3
  • Matthew
    New York City •3 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on 5 Sept 2026
    Tasty, fresh and delicious as always, with fast and easy service. Outstanding!
    More info
    K Pasa$$$$• Tapas / Small Plates• Sag Harbor
    •
    4.6

Discover best restaurants near Bay Street Theatre

Discover the Bay Street Theatre, a vibrant cultural hub that showcases mesmerizing performances and events. Where to Eat Near Bay Street Theatre? The dining scene near Bay Street Theatre offers an array of exciting options that cater to various tastes and occasions. Enjoy Mediterranean flavors with satisfying dishes inspired by Greek and American cuisines, and indulge in contemporary American fare that features fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. You'll find casual dining spaces perfect for family gatherings or a relaxed dinner, as well as elegant spots that set the stage for a memorable night out. Whether you’re in the mood for delicious seafood, hearty steaks, or seasonal comfort classics, there’s something for everyone. Experience the rich flavors and warm ambiance that make dining in this area a delightful prelude to a show.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • OpenTable For Restaurants
  • OpenTable Pricing & Plans
  • OpenTable Support
Join us on
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2026 OpenTable Australia Level 22, 357 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo